Don’t take ‘rubber stamp cognisance’ of charge sheets filed by police, Madras High Court tells judicial officers
The Hindu
Madras High Court condemns "rubber stamp cognisance" by trial courts in criminal cases, orders immediate halt.
The Madras High Court on Wednesday deprecated the practice of trial courts taking “rubber stamp cognisance” of charge sheets filed by the police in criminal cases without any application of mind whatsoever and ordered that such practice should be stopped forthwith.
Justice N. Anand Venkatesh warned that the High Court would be forced to call for explanation from the judicial officer concerned if it comes across any order in which he/she had taken cognisance of the final reports filed by the police without giving any reasons for doing so.
The judge directed the High Court Registry to circulate a copy of his order to all the Principal District Judges in the State so that it could communicated further down the line to all other judicial officers too instructing them to not pass cryptic orders while taking cognisance of offences.
He recalled that a three-judge Bench of the Supreme Court had in Pawan Kumar Sharma versus State of Uttaranchal (2009) expressed suprise over “strange orders” passed by the judicial officers and the “rubber stamp cognisance” taken by them in criminal cases.
The apex court had stated that the judicial officers must apply their mind before issuing summons to the accused on the basis of the final report filed by the police after completing the investigation in criminal cases and find out whether a prima facie case had been made out to issue the summons.
A similar view was taken by another three-judge bench of the Supreme Court in Sunil Bharti Mittal versus Central Bureau of Investigation (2015) wherein it was held that judicial officers must form an opinion, after due application of mind, before proceeding against the accused in a criminal case.
Justice Venkatesh pointed out that he himself had followed the dictum laid down by the Supreme Court in those two judgements and passed a detailed order against such “rubber stamp cognisance” taken by the judicial officers in Shanmugam versus Inspector of Police, Ariyalur (2019).
When fed into Latin, pusilla comes out denoting “very small”. The Baillon’s crake can be missed in the field, when it is at a distance, as the magnification of the human eye is woefully short of what it takes to pick up this tiny creature. The other factor is the Baillon’s crake’s predisposition to present less of itself: it moves about furtively and slides into the reeds at the slightest suspicion of being noticed. But if you are keen on observing the Baillon’s crake or the ruddy breasted crake in the field, in Chennai, this would be the best time to put in efforts towards that end. These birds live amidst reeds, the bulrushes, which are likely to lose their density now as they would shrivel and go brown, leaving wide gaps, thereby reducing the cover for these tiddly birds to stay inscrutable.
ACB report reveals 173 Maharashtra officials not suspended despite corruption allegations since 2012.
The Kaveri 2.0 portal experienced performance issues in December 2024 and January 2025.
The duration of the work in Goshen library in Chintadripet is 12 months; three months have elapsed, and the work would reportedly be completed before the deadline.
Maharashtra minister Chandrashekhar Bawankule said on February 16, 2025, that separate provisions have been made for each welfare scheme and none has been affected by the flagship Mukhyamantri Majhi Ladki Bahin Yojana.
Perplexity AI has launched Deep Research, its AI research tool for free to compete with OpenAI and Google’s research tools.
West Bengal falls short in solar energy capacity, with only 5% of estimated potential installed, BJP criticises Mamata Banerjee.
Two more persons have been arrested and remanded in connection with the double murder case reported under Perambur police station limits in Mayiladuthurai district on February 14, 2025.
Union Minister Suresh Gopi warns officials against taking bribes, emphasizes importance of public service and growth of tourism sector.
Poongodi Mathiarasu, a puppetry enthusiast, aims to spread the art form's therapeutic benefits through workshops and performances.
Tribal healer in Odisha impresses Ayurvedic experts with traditional treatments for chronic diseases, sparking scientific curiosity and conservation efforts.
Understanding the impact of earthquake depth on damage and intensity of shaking in concise detail.
Minister Sekarbabu rededicates renovated tank at Raveeswarar temple in Vyasarpadi, with upcoming temple structure lift and kumbabhishekam.