Feds urge human rights tribunal to dismiss concerns over Jordan's Principle backlog
CBC
The federal government is urging the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal to dismiss a leading First Nations child advocate's concerns about a large backlog of unprocessed Jordan's Principle requests.
In Ottawa this week, a federal lawyer tried to refute allegations that Canada is mismanaging the program that ensures First Nations kids have timely access to essential health products and services.
"This is not a government that is ignoring its obligation under these orders," said Justice Canada lawyer Dayna Anderson.
"Canada has taken extraordinary steps at extraordinary costs to ensure that it's meeting its obligations to First Nations children."
The First Nations Child and Family Caring Society disagrees. The society sparked the hearing through a non-compliance motion alleging Canada's repeated failure to process these applications in a timely way puts kids at risk.
"We know from Canada's own estimates that there's 40,000 requests at a minimum [and] up to 80,000 requests that they haven't even opened or determined," said Cindy Blackstock, the society's executive director, in an interview.
"We are hearing from some of those people who are calling out in desperation to us. We've seen children die waiting for those kinds of determinations and experiencing other serious harms."
The motion is the latest legal skirmish in a 17-year-old human rights complaint about the chronic underfunding of First Nations child and family services, a complaint the tribunal upheld in 2016 ruling.
Blackstock's latest motion alleges Canada is violating past tribunal orders requiring Ottawa correct the underfunding and properly implement Jordan's Principle.
The aim of Jordan's Principle is to reduce delays, helping First Nations kids to access health care, social and educational supports when they need them, with questions about which jurisdiction pays for them to be worked out afterward.
Canada got its chance to refute Blackstock's claim on Tuesday, with Anderson saying the Caring Society's "concerns about backlogs are absolutely valid, but they are not public administration experts," while the society's preferred approach is untested.
"In our view, it's time now to allow Canada to manage its own operations, to allow us to engage with First Nations, and to not have the Caring Society's overly complex approach, frankly in some cases, imposed upon us."
Canada filed a counter-motion arguing the backlog problems and delays can be solved by extending, and in some cases removing, mandatory timelines to respond to Jordan's Principle requests.
Canada ushered in an enormous expansion of the program over eight years, going from spending little cash on very few approvals to billions of dollars and millions of products going out the door quickly, Anderson argued.
This story is part of CBC Health's Second Opinion, a weekly analysis of health and medical science news emailed to subscribers on Saturday mornings. If you haven't subscribed yet, you can do that by clicking here.
Being able to speak Inuktitut on Hockey Night in Canada is like a dream come true for Pujjuut Kusugak.
For Edward Chou, a first-year biochemistry student at the University of Guelph, the symptoms began shortly after lunch on Monday.
Some Indigenous people reacted to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's announcement this week that he would resign once the Liberals select a successor by praising him for his commitment to reconciliation, but others are pointing to unkept promises.
Mélanie Bouchard tries to bring her 13-year-old son everywhere, but car troubles coupled with the cost of an adapted vehicle to fit his wheelchair has left the single mom of four with few options.
One of the oldest public arts funders in North America hired its first Indigenous chief executive officer late last year.
The news caught retired Ottawa police investigator Randy Wisker by surprise.
A day after CBC revealed that a self-styled Vancouver Island "childbirth activist" was under police investigation, a manslaughter charge has been sworn against Gloria Lemay in relation to the death of a newborn last January.
Barry Blanchard, an alpinist and mountain guide who lives in Canmore, Alta., was among 88 people appointed to the Order of Canada, one of the country's highest honours, late last year.
The Louisiana Department of Health said on Monday that a U.S. patient hospitalized with H5N1 bird flu has died, the country's first death from an outbreak of the virus that has sickened dozens of people and millions of poultry and cattle.
A new book chronicles the experiences of Northern Indigenous people at residential schools with a particular look at Grollier Hall and Stringer Hall in Inuvik, N.W.T.
New research shows the rate of myopia among children and teens worldwide has tripled over the past three decades, with a particularly steep increase noted since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020.
Halton Healthcare and Conservation Halton announced in early December they were partnering with a B.C.-based foundation to offer nature prescriptions to patients for free access to the local conservation areas.
A worker digging up clay in a southern England limestone quarry noticed unusual bumps that led to the discovery of a "dinosaur highway" and nearly 200 tracks that date back 166 million years, researchers said Thursday.
It was a feat of determination, said Christina Lennox, who re-created a 1930s photo of their great-grandmother using 87,000 beads.
Michael Cheena says he gets emotional when he reads the names of the 18 residential schools that operated in Ontario on a monument in Spirit Garden in Toronto's Nathan Phillips Square. He attended two of them.
Every year, we get to experience not only the wonders of the sky, but also missions to space that expand our knowledge of our universe.
On Dec. 31, 2019, the World Health Organization first learned about what ended up becoming the worst pandemic in over a century.