Why won't Ontario track the reasons why criminal charges are dropped or stayed?
CBC
Five years ago Ontario's auditor general recommended the province start tracking the reasons criminal charges are withdrawn by prosecutors or stayed by judges — to help reduce costs and ensure cases make it through the system efficiently amid backlogs.
But despite facing bigger backlogs from the pandemic and a rising number of stayed and withdrawn charges, Ontario's Ministry of the Attorney General has refused to track those reasons.
The recommendations stem from a 2019 audit of the province's criminal court system, and were reiterated by Auditor General Shelley Spence this summer.
"If you don't know, you can't manage," Spence told the province's standing committee on justice policy in August.
"We still encourage [the ministry] to capture the data in whatever way makes sense… so that they can actually do something with that analysis to fix the issue and speed up the cases. But what we're seeing is that it's not getting better."
Recent data on criminal charge outcomes in Ontario shows most cases have ended with charges being withdrawn, stayed, dismissed or discharged before a decision at trial since 2020. In 2022-23, the latest fiscal year for which data is available, 56 per cent ended that way — a 14 per cent increase since 2013-14 when guilty decisions still made up most outcomes.
In a statement, a spokesperson for the auditor general said the recommendations were intended to help speed up the progress of cases through the system and reduce the costs caused by delays when charges are withdrawn because there is no reasonable prospect of conviction.
As for stayed cases, the reasons for those would help the ministry understand whether delays were due to prosecutor availability, disclosure of evidence, court scheduling or defence counsel.
Last year the ministry told a provincial committee that the effort and cost associated with reviewing judge's written decisions, transcripts or audio recordings of proceedings to determine all the reasons for a stay of charges as recommended "would not provide value for money."
In terms of the reasons for withdrawing charges, the ministry told the auditor general that tracking them wouldn't benefit the administration of justice and would "risk impacting the judgment of prosecutors."
CBC Toronto asked the ministry how it intends to understand what parties and factors are having the greatest impact on criminal charges being withdrawn by prosecutors and stayed by judges if it does not have aggregate data on those decisions.
In a statement, a spokesperson said the ministry's internal tracking system allows prosecutors to record the specific reason for a stay and the reasons for withdrawals at the individual case level, which can then be reviewed by Crown managers.
But the larger-scale tracking recommended by the auditor general "would risk impacting the ability of prosecutors to assess each and every case individually on its merits," said spokesperson Alexandra Wilkes.
"To address the intent of the auditor's recommendation, the ministry continues to implement and explore initiatives that will reduce the number of cases that would likely result in a withdrawal and reduce the average number of days before a charge is withdrawn."
Two Second Cup café locations at Montreal's Jewish General Hospital have been shut down and the franchise owner's contract terminated after the individual was filmed at a protest on Thursday making "hateful remarks and gestures," according to the Canadian company.
A Toronto woman fears coyotes are becoming more brazen in the city after one attacked her dog right outside her home in Liberty Village last week.
Three men on trial for first-degree murder in the beating death of Chad Kowalchuk have been found guilty of lesser offences after a jury returned its verdict on Day 3 of deliberations.
There's no need to check the record books to see that a very considerable amount of snow fell on the city of Calgary Saturday. A look out the window will do.
Getting the Canadian government to apologize for its role in the mass killing of Nunavik sled dogs has been a 25-year-long mission for Pita Aatami, the president of Makivvik Corporation, which represents Inuit in Nunavik.
A man is dead and five people are injured after a two-car collision in Brampton just after midnight Sunday, police say.
A proposal to make Landlord and Tenant Board (LTB) orders accessible to consumer credit bureaus for tenants with a history of rent arrears would make it easier to weed out bad prospective renters, London, Ont., landlords say.
Amid cuts to staff, programs and student services, Canada's post-secondary system is moving into a stormy period. Students, faculty, post-secondary institutions and experts predict challenging times ahead as colleges and universities report budget shortfalls, exacerbated by federal restrictions on new international students, ongoing domestic tuition caps or freezes, and stagnant provincial funding.
Nobody wants the amount of consistent rain and fog parts of the Avalon Peninsula have seen over the course of this month — except Maria Halfyard.
The Halifax Regional Municipality is gauging interest on cart-based garbage collection.
New Brunswick's child poverty rate continues to steadily rise with inflation and the cost of living.