Why Municipality of Yarmouth is changing the way it will enforce illegal dumping rules
CBC
The Municipality of Yarmouth is changing the way it enforces the rules around illegal dumping.
Last week, officials said the municipality would enforce the reverse onus clause of its solid waste bylaw starting April 1.
In a statement, the municipality said that a person whose name or address is found in the illegally dumped waste is deemed to own the material.
If they fail to prove someone else dumped the garbage, they'll be on the hook for cleanup and served with a summary offence ticket that comes with a fine of up to $5,000. John Cunningham, Yarmouth's warden, told Maritime Noon the municipality has been seeing a "steady increase" in illegal dumping of everything from household garbage to appliances and furniture.
"Just this past fiscal year… there have been 68 separate reports of illegal dumping across the municipality," Cunningham said. "That includes our beaches, our wharves, outside of our parks, our back roads. It's happening everywhere across the municipality."
Cunningham went on to say mailed warnings did nothing to curb illegal dumping and added that the bylaw has been on the books since August 2020.
The bylaw states that "in the absence of evidence to the contrary, if any waste which is deposited or placed in contravention of this by-law bears thereon identifying information connecting that waste to a person then that person shall be deemed to have deposited or placed the offending solid waste or caused or permitted it to be so deposited or placed."
The reverse onus provision requires an accused person to prove or disprove something, essentially presuming them guilty until proven innocent. Previously, there has been concern about the use of the provision violating the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
"I think that it's unconstitutional," said Yarmouth resident Brianne Wright. "I don't think it's right to pass the buck off to … property owners to deal with the dumping problem.
"I don't see how that's going to help deter dumping because the people that are dumping are still going to dump their stuff."
Wright said news of the bylaw has her rethinking her plans to purchase property in the municipality.
As to concerns about the provision's legality, Dalhousie University law professor Wayne MacKay said use of reverse onus in this case doesn't infringe on any Charter rights.
"The section of the Charter guaranteeing the presumption of innocence — which is also therefore opposed to reverse onus that requires you to prove your innocence — only really applies, in most cases, in criminal matters and in some cases other penal matters that are sort of what we call in law quasi-criminal," MacKay said.
He added that since the punishment for breaking the bylaw does not result in serving any jail time, it doesn't violate any Charter rules or other federal law.
Run 3 Space | Play Space Running Game
Traffic Jam 3D | Online Racing Game
Duck Hunt | Play Old Classic Game
This First Person column is written by Chidinma Favour Anosike, who lives in Regina, and is part of a Canada Day series exploring what Canada means to people across this country. For more information about First Person stories, see the FAQ.
Chris Corbin's love of retro video games came from a cousin he lost as a child. His older cousin was a gamer with a few systems, and died at 15 when Corbin was 11.
Three people are dead and one person is seriously injured after two single-vehicle crashes Friday on P.E.I.
When the province announced that most Albertans will have to pay for COVID-19 vaccines themselves going forward, the phones at Mohamed Elfishawi's two Edmonton pharmacies started ringing.
A new research review out of the University of British Columbia (UBC) has found that Indigenous people experience better health outcomes when they speak their traditional languages.
The Toronto Rock are officially coming back to Hamilton.
There's a national overdose hotline that some Canadians call before they're about to use drugs. But the people dialling in aren't who you might think.
Looking for something to do on Canada Day? Good news. There's a lot going on not just in Thunder Bay, but across northwestern Ontario on Tuesday, July 1.
With summer here and school out, families across southwestern Ontario are flocking to Lake Huron and Lake Erie. But with the beauty of the Great Lakes comes real danger, especially for inexperienced swimmers or those unfamiliar with lake conditions.
Forty-seven years after the rainbow Pride flag was first raised, Pride P.E.I. says the symbol still holds deep meaning as a sign of progress and a reminder that more work remains for true inclusion.
Beautiful, long-lasting and supports local harvesters — those are a few reasons why N.W.T. fashion designer D'Arcy Moses wants to incorporate fur knitting into his repertoire, and he's travelled to Ontario to learn how.
Before taking their latest chance to weigh in on the wisdom of exiting the Canada Pension Plan, Albertans must first watch a five-minute video, most of which tries to persuade them how great an idea it is.
Kensington Market's popular Pedestrian Sunday festival is back this month, but its future for the rest of the season remains unclear as organizers look for solutions on safety concerns and the problem of illegal vendors.