Primary Country (Mandatory)

United States

Other Country (Optional)

Set News Language for United States

Primary Language (Mandatory)
English
Other Language[s] (Optional)
No other language available

Set News Language for World

Primary Language (Mandatory)
English
Other Language(s) (Optional)

Set News Source for United States

Primary Source (Mandatory)
CNN
Other Source[s] (Optional)

Set News Source for World

Primary Source (Mandatory)
AajTak
Other Source(s) (Optional)
  • Countries
    • India
    • United States
    • Qatar
    • Germany
    • China
    • Canada
    • World
  • Categories
    • National
    • International
    • Business
    • Entertainment
    • Sports
    • Special
    • All Categories
  • Available Languages for United States
    • English
  • All Languages
    • English
    • Hindi
    • Arabic
    • German
    • Chinese
    • French
  • Sources
    • India
      • AajTak
      • NDTV India
      • The Hindu
      • India Today
      • Zee News
      • NDTV
      • BBC
      • The Wire
      • News18
      • News 24
      • The Quint
      • ABP News
      • Zee News
      • News 24
    • United States
      • CNN
      • Fox News
      • Al Jazeera
      • CBSN
      • NY Post
      • Voice of America
      • The New York Times
      • HuffPost
      • ABC News
      • Newsy
    • Qatar
      • Al Jazeera
      • Al Arab
      • The Peninsula
      • Gulf Times
      • Al Sharq
      • Qatar Tribune
      • Al Raya
      • Lusail
    • Germany
      • DW
      • ZDF
      • ProSieben
      • RTL
      • n-tv
      • Die Welt
      • Süddeutsche Zeitung
      • Frankfurter Rundschau
    • China
      • China Daily
      • BBC
      • The New York Times
      • Voice of America
      • Beijing Daily
      • The Epoch Times
      • Ta Kung Pao
      • Xinmin Evening News
    • Canada
      • CBC
      • Radio-Canada
      • CTV
      • TVA Nouvelles
      • Le Journal de Montréal
      • Global News
      • BNN Bloomberg
      • Métro
Hyaluronic Acid Serum for Face Buy Now
Casio MDV106 Diver's Watch Buy Now
Women's Boho Palazzo Pants Buy Now
Blaosn Athletic Skirts for Women Buy Now
Kaliyadi Polarized Sunglasses for Men Buy Now
Tangle-Free Jump Rope for Fitness Buy Now
Men's Linen Casual Long Pants Buy Now
Under Armour UA Tech™ Team ½ Zip Buy Now
Tracksuits Sweatsuits for Men Buy Now
OLEVS Women Watches Buy Now
Ultrasonic Pest & Insect Repeller Buy Now
Under Eye Patches Buy Now
Rimless Frame Driving Sun glasses Buy Now
Michael Kors Crossbody Bag for Women Buy Now
OLEVS Mens Big Face Watch Buy Now
Aldo Sloana Handbag Buy Now
Hoowel Smart Watch for Men and Women Buy Now
V Neck Batwing Half Sleeve Shirts Solid Color Tops Buy Now
Ninja Air Fryer Pro Buy Now
YuKaiChen Men's Casual Pullover Hoodies Buy Now
MoreBack to News Headlines
The bureaucracy as prosecutor and judge 
Premium

The bureaucracy as prosecutor and judge  Premium

The Hindu
Sunday, August 6, 2023 7:14 PM GMT

There is a backsliding on the separation of powers because of efforts by the bureaucracy to encroach upon judicial powers with the aid of elected Ministers

The controversial Jan Vishwas Act, 2022 which was recently enacted into law by Parliament, has been touted by the government as a landmark piece of legislation aimed at improving “ease of doing business” in India by either decriminalising or making “compoundable” offences across 42 legislations.

The fine print which has received little media attention is that while the legislation has mostly replaced criminal imprisonment with penalties, it has transferred the power to impose these monetary penalties from the judiciary to the bureaucracy. For example, the Jan Vishwas Act amends the Environmental (Protection) Act, 1986 and the Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 to replace imprisonment as a punishment for certain offences with penalties of up to ₹15 lakh that can be imposed by designated bureaucrats (Joint Secretaries). Under amendments to the Indian Forest Act, 1927 forest officers have the power to not just conduct an inquiry to determine the “damage done to the forest” by anybody but also order the offender to pay a hitherto uncapped “compensation” for said damage.

Given the regularity with which India Inc. complains about tax terrorism, there is surprisingly no opposition to giving the bureaucracy the power to be both prosecutor and judge while imposing penalties and ordering the payment of compensation. The larger question is whether giving the bureaucracy, rather than the courts, the power to not just adjudicate a factual dispute but also penalise or order compensation, goes against the constitutional scheme of separation of powers.

Although the Constitution does not mandate a separation of powers between the judiciary and the executive, Article 50 directs the state to achieve it in due time. Such a separation was not achieved until several years after the Constitution came into effect because the criminal magistracy was part of the executive at Independence. It took till approximately 1970, for several State legislatures to effect the separation of power at the level of the criminal magistracy through laws such as The West Bengal Separation of Judicial and Executive Functions Act, 1970 which separated the roles of the judicial and executive magistrates in the Criminal Procedure Code, 1898.

The saga of protecting judicial independence from the roving eye of the bureaucracy did not end with the separation of the criminal magistracy from the executive. Since the 1980s, the bureaucracy has tried three different routes to capture judicial power.

First, different Ministries began creating judicial tribunals to take over various judicial functions hitherto exercised by the judiciary. Most of these tribunals were created in a manner to give bureaucrats an opportunity to be appointed to the tribunals as “technical members”.

Second, the Union government began creating a new class of statutory regulators such as the Securities and Exchange Board of India, and the Competition Commission of India (CCI) which had powers to punish the private sector with punishing fines. Virtually all these regulators ended up being headed by senior bureaucrats.

Read full story on The Hindu
Share this story on:-
Run 3 Space | Play Space Running GamePlay Run 3, the ultimate space tunnel running game with 300+ challenging levels!Adv.
Traffic Jam 3D | Online Racing GameTraffic Jam 3D is a game where you’ll be driving through heavy traffic.Adv.
Duck Hunt | Play Old Classic GamePlay the classic 1984 light gun shooter game Duck Hunt on your browser.Adv.
More Related News
Schools reopen in Puducherry after summer vacation

Schools in Puducherry and Karaikal regions reopen with festive welcome for students after summer vacation.

Maharashtra records 873 COVID-19 cases since January, 10 deaths reported 

Maharashtra sees rise in COVID-19 cases, with 873 infections and 10 deaths reported, testing and surveillance ongoing.

Ramanathapuram Collector distributes 60 tonnes of Kappaphycus seed to women cultivators

Ramanathapuram Collector distributes Kappaphycus seed to support seaweed farming, benefiting women cultivators in Tamil Nadu coastal areas.

No language as tolerant as Kannada: Banu Mushtaq

He observed that Ms. Mushtaq had the courage to write against superstition and as the voice of Muslim women. Mr. Siddaramaiah said that literature has the power to build bridges in society and writers should strive to unite people rather than create divisions, he added.

Differently abled persons protest demanding proper assessment

TARATDAC protests for proper disability assessment and facilities at Dindigul Government Medical College Hospital.

Rare migratory bird sighted on Kappad beach five years ago identified as Caspian Gull

Kozhikode ornithologist confirms rare sighting of Caspian Gull in Kerala after five years of identification efforts.

Ponguleti says Revenue Department at the ‘People’s Doorstep’ from Tuesday

Minister for Revenue emphasizes empathy and fairness in resolving land disputes, launching proactive Revenue Sadassu meetings across mandals.

Centre calls for proposals to set up de-addiction centres in 291 ‘gap’ districts

Government invites proposals for District De-Addiction Centres in 291 "gap" districts to address substance abuse nationwide.

GCC to appoint consultants to monitor road relaying work at a cost of ₹7.5 crore in 3,000 stretches

Greater Chennai Corporation plans to re-engage quality controllers for monitoring road projects across the city, valued at ₹7.5 crore.

153 acre green space to come up soon in North Bengaluru 

KFDC Chairman Basavaraju Neelappa Shivannavar formally handed over the land to Environment Minister Eshwar Khandre, who said a huge biological park would be developed on that piece of land in the coming days. Mr. Khandre said that the proposed park would be a much-needed green space for north Bengaluru once developed.

Rahul Gandhi to launch campaign to revamp Congress in Madhya Pradesh 

Madhya Pradesh Congress prepares for Rahul Gandhi's visit to revamp party ahead of 2028 Assembly elections.

SWR General Manager inspects Subrahmanya Road Station

South Western Railway's GM inspects Subrahmanya Road Station redevelopment, emphasizes quality and safety, reviews electrification progress.

SARAS exhibition debuts in Parvatipuram

SARAS exhibition in Parvatipuram showcases rural artisans' work, with 60 stalls and local festival integration, attracting residents and officials.

Parking Slot | Free Parking GamePlay Parking Slot, the best online 3D car driving and parking game.Adv.
Slope Ball Run - Play OnlineSlope Game takes you on an exciting journey of a ball on special paths.Adv.
Morning Digest: INDIA bloc to push for special session of parliament on Pahalgam attack; Pakistan too sends delegations abroad to present its case, and more

The Hindu Morning Digest: June 03, 2025

News Analysis: Ahead of polls, all eyes in Bihar on Chirag Paswan’s next political move Premium

Bihar's political landscape heats up as Chirag Paswan considers contesting Assembly election from a general seat.

Telangana govt. to develop 80-acres Eco-Town modelled on Japanese city Kitakyushu 

Telangana government to establish Eco-Town inspired by Kitakyushu City, focusing on sustainability and collaboration with Japan.

Ennore: Where industrial growth has made life difficult for residents Premium

Residents of Ennore struggle with pollution, impacting health and livelihoods, while demanding government intervention and industry accountability.

Security forces seize over two tonne of explosives stolen by Maoists in Odisha

Security forces recover 2.5 tonnes of stolen explosives from Maoists in Odisha, sparking a joint combing operation.

University of Madras staff and faculty to receive their salary today

Higher education secretary working to improve University of Madras finances, addressing salary delays and budget cuts.

Rahul Gandhi approaches Jharkhand High Court challenging a non-bailable warrant

Congress leader Rahul Gandhi challenges non-bailable warrant in Jharkhand High Court related to defamation case filed by BJP leader.

In a first in A.P., Vizag to house anti-drug park and glow garden

Visakhapatnam to have unique theme parks - anti-drug park and glow garden, first of their kind in Andhra Pradesh.

For most residents of Pakistan Tola in Bihar, the village name is an embarrassment

Pakistan Tola, a village in Bihar, faces challenges due to its name, sparking a movement for change.

Cancer screening camp on World No Tobacco Day

The camp was attended by newspaper vendors from the Indore Newspaper Association

Schools in Dindigul district reopen after summer vacation

Children in Dindigul return to school with warm welcome, new supplies, and focus on education and healthcare by government.

Hoardings that pose a threat to public safety yet to be removed

Kerala SHRC directive to remove dangerous hoardings in Kozhikode city not implemented, posing public safety risks.

© 2008 - 2025 Webjosh  |  News Archive  |  Privacy Policy  |  Contact Us