Supreme Court says mandatory minimum sentences for child luring unconstitutional
CBC
The Supreme Court of Canada ruled Friday that mandatory minimum sentences for child luring are overly broad and can result in sentences that violate the Charter of Rights' protection against cruel and unusual punishment.
"The mandatory periods of incarceration apply to such an exceptionally wide scope of conduct that the result is grossly disproportionate punishments in reasonably foreseeable scenarios." the ruling said.
In a six to one decision, with Justice Suzanne Côté partly dissenting, the court ruled on two cases from the Quebec Court of Appeal.
In both cases, the mandatory minimum sentences of one year for an indictment and six months for a summary offence were found to have violated Section 12 of the charter.
Section 12 states that "everyone has the right not to be subjected to any cruel and unusual treatment or punishment."
Despite that ruling, both cases resulted in the guilty parties having longer sentences imposed upon them during their journey through the courts.
In the first case, Maxime Marchand met his 13-year-old victim when he was 22, sent her a friend request on Facebook and remained in contact with the child for two years. The pair met and had "illegal sexual intercourse" on four separate occasions.
Marchand pleaded guilty to one count of child luring and one count of sexual interference. At sentencing, he challenged the one-year mandatory minimum sentence for child luring, saying it violated Section 12.
Marchand's arguments were successful and he was instead sentenced to five months for child luring, to be served at the same time as the sentence for sexual interference.
In the second case, H.V., whose name was covered by a publication ban to shield the victim, pleaded guilty to one count of child luring for sending sexual text messages to the victim over a period of 10 days.
H.V. also challenged as unconstitutional the mandatory minimum sentence of six months under summary conviction for luring.
The judge agreed and imposed a sentence of two years' probation and 150 hours of community service.
On appeal, the judge found that mandatory minimum sentences for luring were indeed unconstitutional but changed the sentence to a four month prison term.
In its decision, the country's top court said that striking down mandatory minimums was about the overly broad nature of the law, rather than any attempt to minimize the offence of child luring.
Run 3 Space | Play Space Running Game
Traffic Jam 3D | Online Racing Game
Duck Hunt | Play Old Classic Game
"Did you kill Lilly and Jack?"
Toronto residents should brace for a stretch of very hot weather early next week.
A new base for paramedics in the western P.E.I. community of O'Leary has finally risen from the ashes after an electrical fire claimed the original building nearly two years ago.
Yellowknife resident Kim Harrower is a regular at the city's Willow Flats area, where she walks and listens to the birds in the morning. She says the wetland area there is good bird habitat, and it brings the community together.
As a former top Finance Department official, Susan Peterson played a key role years ago in creating the stable Canada Pension Plan that we see today. But even she was surprised by the numbers.
Metrolinx has begun construction on a pedestrian tunnel linking UP Express Bloor Station to the nearby Dundas West subway station, nearly a decade after it was announced.
Three New Brunswick timber companies are seeking to have their forestry lands excluded from the Wolastoqey Nation's Indigenous title claim that's working its way through the courts.
It could be at least another week before wildfire evacuees from a northern Manitoba First Nation are able to go home, leadership says.
The Saskatchewan government has informed Crown employees it will extend the life of all its coal-fired power plants, setting up a potential legal battle with the federal government over environmental regulations.
The B.C. government said Wednesday it will be pulling funding for an extremely expensive drug used by one person in the province — a young Vancouver Island girl.
After two years of negotiations, Health P.E.I. has reached an agreement on wages for support services staff that the union representing the workers is calling "historic."
Iranian-Canadians are trying desperately to get in touch with friends and family in Iran as missiles fall and routes out of the country are limited.
Ontario Premier Doug Ford says he is willing to give First Nations what they want for their support in developing mines, but they cannot "keep coming hat in hand all the time to the government" for more money.