Primary Country (Mandatory)

United States

Other Country (Optional)

Set News Language for United States

Primary Language (Mandatory)
English
Other Language[s] (Optional)
No other language available

Set News Language for World

Primary Language (Mandatory)
English
Other Language(s) (Optional)

Set News Source for United States

Primary Source (Mandatory)
CNN
Other Source[s] (Optional)

Set News Source for World

Primary Source (Mandatory)
AajTak
Other Source(s) (Optional)
  • Countries
    • India
    • United States
    • Qatar
    • Germany
    • China
    • Canada
    • World
  • Categories
    • National
    • International
    • Business
    • Entertainment
    • Sports
    • Special
    • All Categories
  • Available Languages for United States
    • English
  • All Languages
    • English
    • Hindi
    • Arabic
    • German
    • Chinese
    • French
  • Sources
    • India
      • AajTak
      • NDTV India
      • The Hindu
      • India Today
      • Zee News
      • NDTV
      • BBC
      • The Wire
      • News18
      • News 24
      • The Quint
      • ABP News
      • Zee News
      • News 24
    • United States
      • CNN
      • Fox News
      • Al Jazeera
      • CBSN
      • NY Post
      • Voice of America
      • The New York Times
      • HuffPost
      • ABC News
      • Newsy
    • Qatar
      • Al Jazeera
      • Al Arab
      • The Peninsula
      • Gulf Times
      • Al Sharq
      • Qatar Tribune
      • Al Raya
      • Lusail
    • Germany
      • DW
      • ZDF
      • ProSieben
      • RTL
      • n-tv
      • Die Welt
      • Süddeutsche Zeitung
      • Frankfurter Rundschau
    • China
      • China Daily
      • BBC
      • The New York Times
      • Voice of America
      • Beijing Daily
      • The Epoch Times
      • Ta Kung Pao
      • Xinmin Evening News
    • Canada
      • CBC
      • Radio-Canada
      • CTV
      • TVA Nouvelles
      • Le Journal de Montréal
      • Global News
      • BNN Bloomberg
      • Métro
MoreBack to News Headlines
Supreme Court says mandatory minimum sentences for child luring unconstitutional

Supreme Court says mandatory minimum sentences for child luring unconstitutional

CBC
Friday, November 3, 2023 6:59 PM GMT

The Supreme Court of Canada ruled Friday that mandatory minimum sentences for child luring are overly broad and can result in sentences that violate the Charter of Rights' protection against cruel and unusual punishment.

"The mandatory periods of incarceration apply to such an exceptionally wide scope of conduct that the result is grossly disproportionate punishments in reasonably foreseeable scenarios." the ruling said.

In a six to one decision, with Justice Suzanne Côté partly dissenting, the court ruled on two cases from the Quebec Court of Appeal.

In both cases, the mandatory minimum sentences of one year for an indictment and six months for a summary offence were found to have violated Section 12 of the charter.

Section 12 states that "everyone has the right not to be subjected to any cruel and unusual treatment or punishment."

Despite that ruling, both cases resulted in the guilty parties having longer sentences imposed upon them during their journey through the courts.

In the first case, Maxime Marchand met his 13-year-old victim when he was 22, sent her a friend request on Facebook and remained in contact with the child for two years. The pair met and had "illegal sexual intercourse" on four separate occasions.

Marchand pleaded guilty to one count of child luring and one count of sexual interference. At sentencing, he challenged the one-year mandatory minimum sentence for child luring, saying it violated Section 12.

Marchand's arguments were successful and he was instead sentenced to five months for child luring, to be served at the same time as the sentence for sexual interference.

In the second case, H.V., whose name was covered by a publication ban to shield the victim, pleaded guilty to one count of child luring for sending sexual text messages to the victim over a period of 10 days.

H.V. also challenged as unconstitutional the mandatory minimum sentence of six months under summary conviction for luring.

The judge agreed and imposed a sentence of two years' probation and 150 hours of community service. 

On appeal, the judge found that mandatory minimum sentences for luring were indeed unconstitutional but changed the sentence to a four month prison term.

In its decision, the country's top court said that striking down mandatory minimums was about the overly broad nature of the law, rather than any attempt to minimize the offence of child luring.

Read full story on CBC
Share this story on:-
Run 3 Space | Play Space Running GamePlay Run 3, the ultimate space tunnel running game with 300+ challenging levels!Adv.
Traffic Jam 3D | Online Racing GameTraffic Jam 3D is a game where you’ll be driving through heavy traffic.Adv.
Duck Hunt | Play Old Classic GamePlay the classic 1984 light gun shooter game Duck Hunt on your browser.Adv.
More Related News
'I have a life back': How ketamine therapy is helping these Nova Scotians find relief from depression

For decades, Sherri Topple's world was overshadowed by the crushing weight of depression that no medication or therapy seemed to fix.

South end space for arts and community groups in Saint John could become housing

Saint John council has taken steps toward approving a B.C. developer's plan to turn a former church that became home to arts and community groups into a residential and commercial building.

Chief calls on province to use emergency measures to free up Manitoba hotels

A First Nations chief is calling on the Manitoba government to use the Emergency Measures Act to free up hotel space in Winnipeg to help house thousands of wildfire evacuees.

Some Sask. evacuees forced to find far-flung rooms on their own as wildfires put pressure on hotels

Maureen and Greg McBratney didn't have many options for places to stay when wildfire forced them to leave their home in Denare Beach, Sask., late last week.

Edmonton Public Schools cuts number of seclusion rooms, but confinement continues

Advocates demanding an end to the use of seclusion rooms say they're pleased the Edmonton public school division has decommissioned more than 60 of them in the last year.

Fleeing wildfires, hundreds from Manitoba First Nations settle into Niagara Falls, Ont. hotels

As wildfires burn out of control near their communities, hundreds of Manitoba First Nations residents have been put up in hotels in Niagara Falls, Ont. — for some around 1,800 kilometres away from their homes.

Liberal legislation to further tighten Canada-U.S. border expected today

Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree is expected to introduce a bill today spelling out the federal government's next steps on border security.

Too many schools still asking why, not how to implement Indigenous curriculum, says son of late TRC chair

When Niigaan Sinclair visits schools, he always asks, "How many of you have an orange shirt in your closet that you pull out at least once a year?" 

First Nation chiefs share safety concerns amid wildfire evacuations in northwestern Ontario

As wildfire evacuees from northwestern Ontario settle in at their accommodations in the southern part of the province, community chiefs are raising concerns about what happens next.

Grab the sunscreen and some water — things are heating up in Waterloo region this week

Sunny, hazy and hot. 

P.E.I. woman, 1 of many arrested last weekend for impaired driving, tested 3.6 times over limit

Police in Prince Edward Island arrested several people for impaired driving over the weekend, with one in particular allegedly testing over three times the legal limit of alcohol.

Whitehorse hospital opens $33M mental health unit

The Whitehorse hospital says its new mental health unit is going to transform in-patient mental-health care.

Why Alberta politics may be getting more polarized — and why that matters

EDITOR'S NOTE: CBC News commissioned this public opinion research to be conducted immediately following the federal election and leading into the second anniversary of the United Conservative Party's provincial election win in May 2023. 

Parking Slot | Free Parking GamePlay Parking Slot, the best online 3D car driving and parking game.Adv.
Slope Ball Run - Play OnlineSlope Game takes you on an exciting journey of a ball on special paths.Adv.
Nobody hurt in Whitehorse house fire, 1 cat receiving medical care

A house fire in Whitehorse's McIntyre subdivision has destroyed one home and damaged another. 

Is another 'grand bargain' necessary to build another pipeline?

At question period on Monday, two Conservative MPs beseeched the government to approve a pipeline that very afternoon.

Calgary to 'welcome the world' as airport expects more than 5.8M travellers this summer

Calgarians can expect the city to be especially busy this summer.

Here's where wildfire smoke is spreading in Canada and the U.S.

As wildfires continue to rage in Western Canada, communities in affected areas and surrounding provinces have been blanketed by thick plumes of smoke, prompting air quality alerts extending into parts of the United States this week.

ATV riders 'ecstatic' about opening of 12 km of pilot trails in eastern P.E.I.

All-terrain vehicle riders on P.E.I. are now one step closer to having a provincewide trail network, thanks to four new pilot roads in the southeastern end of the Island.

Teen dies after falling through ice near Pangnirtung, Nunavut

A 15-year-old boy is dead after he and two other people fell through the ice near Pangnirtung, Nunavut.

2 men charged with 1st-degree murder linked to Brampton man's death

Two men have been arrested in British Columbia and charged with first-degree murder in connection with the death of 51-year old Brampton man Harjeet Dhadda.

1 year in, teachers' union says phone ban boosts students' focus, but more action needed

It's been nearly a full school year since Prince Edward Island introduced restrictions on cellphone use for students, and teachers say they're seeing positive results.

Pimicikamak chief frustrated with residents refusing to flee wildfire, says arrests should be made

Pimicikamak Cree Nation leaders are still working to get the final few community members to safety as emergency crews fight an out-of-control wildfire, and Chief David Monias is exasperated with residents who've refused to leave.

Ford says deal with U.S. is 'very close,' despite 50% tariffs on the horizon

Ontario Premier Doug Ford said he thinks the U.S. and Canada are closing in on a trade deal, as the country braces to be slapped with an additional 25 per cent tariff on Wednesday. 

How to deal with your — and your child's — anxiety during wildfire season

Nearly 100 wildfires have been reported in Newfoundland and Labrador so far this year, marking an early and active start to the season that has already claimed 12 homes on the island and threatened a community in central Labrador.

Northeastern Ontario food banks, health units call for government action to address rising food insecurity

Rates of food insecurity continue to rise in communities across Ontario, including in northeastern Ontario, according to a number of organizations and agencies in the region.

© 2008 - 2025 Webjosh  |  News Archive  |  Privacy Policy  |  Contact Us