Supreme Court closes its eyes to big ticket projects, says Justice Swaminathan
The Hindu
Justice G.R. Swaminathan of Madras High Court discusses Supreme Court's negligence of environment in big ticket projects & increasing infections in elephants due to destruction of wildlife.
The Supreme Court “closes its eyes” when it comes to big ticket projects involving environment, Justice G.R. Swaminathan of the Madras High Court said here on Sunday.
At a seminar on ‘Elephant and the Law,’ organised jointly by the Madurai Bar Association of Madurai Bench of Madras High Court and the Wildlife Trust of India, he said: “Though the Supreme Court has passed various judgments related to environment citing Article 21, it closes its eyes when it is about big issues.”
Citing the Koodankulam Nuclear Power Plant case, he said the Supreme Court had shied away from going beyond a limit to ask questions after the government replied that all safety standards had been adhered to. “They behave in a similar manner in all big-ticket projects such as Tehri dam and Narmada dam, and accept whatever the executive claims as right,” he added.
He further said that the Supreme Court neglected the case of environmental scientist N.D. Jayal, who argued that big dam projects at Tehri in Uttarakhand would cause natural disasters and asked them to stop the projects. But, 20 years after the judgment, what Jayal feared was happening, he added.
Similarly, he said that in the Goa second airport case, Chief Justice of India D.Y. Chandrachaud suspended the project as the project proponent falsely presented facts to obtain permission. The judgment for suspension of the project was widely appreciated, but within a year, it was lifted and nod was given for the project, he pointed out.
He further said: “Chennai floods have taught us on which side we should stand – environment or development.”
N. Kalaivannan, Forest Veterinary Assistant Surgeon, Srivilliputhur Megamalai Tiger Reserve, said instances of animals, particularly elephants, contracting infections such as tuberculosis have been increasing in the State.
Bombay High Court grants bail to Chetan Patil in Shivaji statue collapse case; sculptor Jaydeep Apte's plea pending.
Deadly rinderpest outbreak devastates Mudumalai Wildlife Sanctuary, highlighting the threat of diseases from domestic cattle to wild populations.
Suryanarkoil Mutt's history, traditions, and leadership succession explained in detail with references and comparisons to other Saivaite Mutts.
Upalokayukta takes action against officials for neglecting century-old Kelageri Tank in Dharwad, setting 20-day deadline for rejuvenation.
On World Fisheries Day, India launches projects for marine and inland aquaculture, aiming to transform the fisheries sector and blue economy.
Lokayukta police raid uncovers ₹26.6 crore in assets from government officials in Karnataka, leading to investigations and cases filed.
Court boycott by advocates in Tamil Nadu demands Advocates Protection Bill for safety, affecting litigants from remote villages.
Army faces allegations of harassment and torture in Kishtwar, Jammu; probe ordered, sparking concerns over human rights violations.
Karnataka’s software and services exports crossed ₹4.11 lakh crore during fiscal 2023-24 (March 2024) from ₹3.2 lakh crore a year ago, marking a 27% year-on-year growth, Minister for IT&BT, Priyank Kharge, said here on Thursday quoting Software Technology Parks of India (STPI) data.
Continuous rainfall in Thoothukudi has caused severe hardship for residents as rainwater has inundated several areas. Efforts to drain stagnant water in the city have been intensified
Indictment details Adani bribery scheme to secure solar power contracts, involving Adani Green Energy and Azure Power executives.