Sask. appeal court gives 2 thumbs up to decision that emoji is contractually binding
CBC
Saskatchewan's Court of Appeal has upheld a prior decision that a thumbs-up emoji was confirmation of a contract between two agricultural companies.
Achter Land & Cattle Ltd appealed a 2023 decision from the Court of King's Bench that its owner had agreed to sell flax to a grain buyer from South West Terminal (SWT) when he responded to a text containing photos of the $58,000 contract with a thumbs-up emoji.
Achter Land & Cattle grows and sells grain. The company has sold grain to SWT since about 2012, according to court documents.
In March 2021, an SWT employee sent a photo of the front of a double-sided contract to Chris Achter with a message that read, "Please confirm flax contract."
The employee, Kent Mickleborough, said he spoke with Achter and Achter's father, who helps with farm operations, and reached a verbal agreement to buy the flax at $17 per bushel, with delivery deferred until the fall.
A Court of King's Bench decision in June found that the thumbs-up emoji was confirmation of the contract, despite Achter's argument that he never signed the contract.
Josh Morrison, counsel for South West Terminal, said modern law is media-neutral. He said the text message exchange was the contract — which included the photo of the contract and its details, the message asking for confirmation and the thumbs up emoji.
"It's no real different than the words that he texted in previous contracts — OK, looks good, yup — the thumbs-up emoji is just a different way of communicating," he said.
The court ruled that the metadata from a personal cellphone was enough to consider the emoji a personal signature.
Achter Land & Cattle "did not harvest a single bushel of flax" that year, according to Achter's evidence.
When time came to deliver the flax, sometime between September and November, the price had increased by $24 a bushel.
The Court of King's Bench ruled that Achter must pay SWT the difference, about $82,200 in damages, plus interest, because of the breach of contract, among other costs.
Morrison said the Achter Land & Cattle's next course of action could be to take the case to the Supreme Court of Canada, but the court weould have to decide the case hold's national importance for it to be heard.
Morrison said it's unclear if the case sets precedent, because the two parties had a history of previous contracts to base this ruling on.
For the second time in just over a year, the Town of Three Rivers had to limit access to a public meeting after threats of violence.
The Alberta Teachers’ Association (ATA) is accusing the province’s negotiating body of “bad-faith bargaining” regarding its commitment to hiring more teachers.
The man behind micro-shelters once placed in Toronto's St. James Park is continuing his work even after the city removed them — and for one unhoused man, it's made all the difference.
A phone call where the person on the other end can’t hear a word you're saying — that’s what Nathalie-Isabelle Richard says it's like trying to call someone in Iqaluit these days.
Ottawa will provide an additional $1.17 billion to Alberta in order to extend the federal-provincial subsidized child-care program for another year.
Toronto has cancelled an automated traffic enforcement pilot intended to help fight congestion in the wake of the provincial government’s ban on speed cameras in Ontario, CBC Toronto has learned.
Some Tahltan First Nation members in northern B.C. are raising concerns about the timing of an “upfront payment” from a mining company ahead of a crucial vote on the Eskay Creek mine.
To illustrate the incredible upheaval that federal politics in Canada has experienced over the last 12 months, one could do worse than to simply look at the last two Liberal caucus holiday parties.
Alberta’s auditor general says he was denied information he requested from the Department of Municipal Affairs while attempting to assess flood mitigation systems.
Flooding in B.C.'s Fraser Valley, caused by overflow from the Nooksack River in Washington state, is expected to reach its peak Friday, as highways and some schools remain closed and residents assess the damage.
Three Scottish men accused in the 2023 killing of Ontario restaurant owner Sharif Rahman after a dispute over an unpaid bill appeared in an Owen Sound court Friday morning after their extradition to Canada.
A provincially appointed supervisor has fired the director of education at Ontario's largest school board, amid a shakeup of board governance by the education minister.
A Calgary Transit shuttle bus went up in flames Friday morning.