Ontario court throws out request by Hamilton MPP Sarah Jama to overturn Ford government's censorship of her
CBC
Hamilton Centre MPP Sarah Jama will continue to be censured at Queen's Park after an Ontario court dismissed her application for a Progressive Conservative motion to be overturned.
A panel of three justices ruled last week that the dispute is a matter of "parliamentary privilege," which allows elected officials to have free speech within the Legislative Assembly. That's what the members of parliament did when they denounced a statement Jama posted to social media platform X and decided to censure her, the decision says.
Therefore, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice determined, it doesn't have the authority to intervene.
"With this disappointing decision, the court is essentially stating that the Ontario Legislature can, with impunity, censor an elected opposition member with whom it disagrees," Jama said in a statement emailed to CBC Hamilton.
"The courts are requesting I resolve this issue through political means. However, that would require me to fulfill the request of the Speaker of the legislature, who has advised that before I can again be recognized I must disavow the statements that got me censured."
In an Oct. 10 post, Jama, then an NDP MPP, called for a ceasefire as well as an "end to all occupation of Palestinian land."
She did not specifically mention that Hamas had attacked Israel days before, killing about 1,200 civilians and taking about 250 hostages. The post drew condemnation from Premier Doug Ford who claimed it was anti-Semitic and condoning Hamas' violence.
Jama apologized but refused to delete the post and Ford's PC Party passed the censorship motion. Jama has not been allowed to speak in the Legislative Assembly since, although she can vote, participate in committees and table motions.
Since the Hamas attack over seven months ago, Israel's subsequent military invasion into Gaza has killed more than 36,000 Palestinians, according to Gaza's health ministry.
The Israeli government says 130 hostages remain unaccounted for.
Jama and her lawyers appealled to Ontario Divisional Court in December for the motion to be quashed and declare it unconstitutional. They argued the motion was an abuse of power, designed to curtail Jama's right to engage in political speech as an MPP.
The court's decision said Jama, now an Independent MPP, would have to find a resolution within the Legislative Assembly system.
This application is separate from Jama's threat to sue Ford for defamation. She served him with a cease and desist letter on Oct. 11 about his post stating she has "a long and well-documented history of antisemitism."
Jama's letter called the premier's post "reckless and malicious" and an attempt to "tarnish her reputation."
Snow and freezing rain could affect morning commutes on Tuesday, according to a special weather statement issued by Environment Canada.
Daniel Jolivet, 68, had his first taste of freedom this weekend after spending the last 33 years behind bars.
Peguis First Nation is suing former chief Glenn Hudson over allegations he failed to act in the best interest of the band and financially benefitted from breaches of duty — including claims that he enriched himself, his family and supporters.
The Saskatchewan NDP's pace in 2025 has been frenetic.
If you’re ever walking down this east Hamilton neighbourhood during the holiday season, there’s a festive house that just might grab your attention.
It was just a few months ago that U.S. President Donald Trump told the world he doesn’t want Canadian cars.
Flu cases across Canada are on the rise and may push hospitals to their limits over the holidays and into the new year, leading health officials in regions across the country to warn people not to visit emergency rooms unless it's absolutely necessary.
More than 30 years after Canada's military allowed women to serve in combat roles, it's now specifically designing uniforms and body armour to fit their bodies.
The holiday season has arrived in Thunder Bay, and that means reduced hours, or closures, for businesses, city offices, and other amenities.
As Toronto’s food scene continues to grow, some in the industry say the pool of professional chefs hasn’t kept up with demand.
Police have charged a truck driver from the Hamilton area in a hit-and-run crash that killed a tow truck operator who had been stopped while helping a driver on the side of Highway 401 outside Woodstock, Ont.
Power has been restored to most of Haines Junction after a problem earlier on Monday at the local generating station.
A 56-year-old man will return to court on Tuesday for a charge of second-degree murder, laid in a case London police have called an act of femicide.