Multimillionaire calls CRA negligent, wants $4.8M tax bill thrown out
CBC
A British Canadian money manager who's been at odds with the Canada Revenue Agency for more than a decade wants a judge to toss out a nearly $5 million bill for back taxes, saying the CRA never sent it to him and now it's too late.
Whether Charles Shaker, 44, has to pay up may hinge on the proficiency of the CRA's mail department.
An auditor concluded in March 2017 that the former Ottawa-area resident owed $3.8 million in extra taxes for 2008 and 2009, according to court records, based on calculations that he had derived millions of dollars in undeclared personal benefits like car and condo fee payments from a financial planning and consulting company he owned. With penalties and interest, the amount has grown to $4.8 million.
But in addition to disputing those numbers, Shaker alleges the CRA omitted a basic step: It never properly sent him notice that it had reassessed him, or any indication of the amount it wanted him to pay. He's contesting the bill in Tax Court, asking a judge to set it aside.
"The CRA has proffered no evidence that it gave Mr. Shaker any notice whatsoever of the alleged tax debt," his lawyers wrote in a separate but related proceeding last year.
"The CRA is legally required to provide the debtor with proper notice…. Accordingly, there is not, and never has been, any valid tax debt owed by Mr. Shaker."
The CRA wouldn't comment directly on its dispute with Shaker, citing the ongoing court case and taxpayer privacy. It hasn't yet filed its response in Tax Court and has obtained three extensions to the normal deadline.
CBC News emailed Shaker and his tax lawyer Jeff Pniowsky last month and earlier this month requesting comment. Criminal defence lawyer Brian Greenspan replied a week later — saying he'd "been requested to respond" — and that Shaker "vigorously and unequivocally denies any suggestion of impropriety or wrongdoing and will take appropriate action with respect to any renewed attempt to tarnish his reputation by an innuendo of suspicion."
The CRA does indeed have to send a notice of assessment or reassessment — within required time frames — before it can start trying to collect on any debt, says David Rotfleisch, a Toronto accountant and tax lawyer who isn't involved in the litigation.
"The CRA has the onus of proving, 'Yeah, we sent it,'" he said. "It's not a hard onus. They just have to show that someone mailed it," to the most recent address that the taxpayer provided.
Otherwise, "the CRA is out of luck."
Shaker appears to have landed on the CRA's radar in 2010 largely because his name was on a leaked list of 130,000 people and entities with ties to confidential accounts at HSBC's private bank in Geneva, according to court records from an earlier case.
A CBC News investigation last year found records in a number of tax-haven data leaks showing he at one point owned or was a director of several offshore companies in the British Virgin Islands and Barbados.
After the CRA spent more than five years looking into his dealings, it issued a notice of reassessment to Shaker on March 31, 2017, a tax officer says in a sworn statement filed in one of his earlier court cases.
It's small things, like a cigarette or a pair of clean socks, Rachel Montour says, that can go a long way to make you feel more human when you’re out on the street.
Several dozen members of Windsor's Chaldean community and its supporters celebrated in the cold at the corner of Marentette Avenue and Wyandotte Street East Friday, as city officials gave a secondary name to the section of Marentette between Wyandotte and Tuscarora Street: Chaldean Way.
Allison Hill says she tries to make people’s experience at the Thunder Bay Food Bank “as pleasant as possible.”
Two years after a man went missing in Scarborough, Toronto police are renewing the investigation in hopes that the public will bring forward more information.
A musical instrument created in Guelph, Ont., has been thrust onto the international stage — or rather, screen.
More than 1,000 Maritime Electric customers are without power after high winds blew across the Island Friday night into Saturday.
The Supreme Court of Canada is deliberating a case that could shape the way sentences are handed down in cases where both the offender and victim are Indigenous, which some Nunavut lawyers say could have ramifications for the Inuit-majority territory.
A man barricaded in a former church in Welland, Ont., was taken into custody early Saturday, nearly 24 hours into a standoff that began over a fence dispute.
Peel police are investigating after a Friday night shooting in Mississauga left one person dead, police said.
Another busy construction season has come to an end in London, and the city is already looking ahead to next spring when a slew of new projects are expected to begin.
Prime Minister Mark Carney has begun to lay out publicly what he sees as boundaries when dealing with China, as his government wades into a new relationship with the economic giant.
Ferry crossings are cancelled and over a thousand households are left without power Saturday morning, due to high winds and severe weather conditions.
Tens of thousands of Nova Scotia Power customers are waking up without power on Saturday morning after high winds and rain hit the province on Friday night.