Laurentian University, Ontario auditor general argue right to privileged documents in value-for-money audit
CBC
A judge has reserved his decision after arguments in Ontario Superior Court over whether the auditor general has the right to unfettered access to privileged documents as she conducts a value-for-money audit of creditor-protected Laurentian University.
The Ontario Legislature's standing committee on public accounts asked the auditor general to audit Laurentian's operations from 2010- 2020 in an effort to reveal what led to the institution's insolvency declaration on Feb. 1.
The university continues to restructure after deep cuts to programming and human resources as well as dealing with a 14 per cent decline in enrolment this year, and ongoing real estate and operational reviews.
Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk has been asked to shed light on what led to the first-ever time a public-sector institution declared insolvency under the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA), allowing it to operate as it worked on its financial struggles, and is seeking information that is normally highly protected between lawyers and their clients.
As the lawyer for Laurentian University, Brian Gover, described in his opening remarks, "Everyone has the right to consult with their lawyers in private. Privilege is a fundamental civil and constitutional right. It is a principle of fundamental justice. Exceptions from that principle must be random, narrow and justified by absolute necessity."
In a statement filed to the court, Laurentian listed the wide range of documents the auditor general is seeking.
The lawyers for both sides focused on Section 10 of the Auditor General Act that was amended in 2004 to add three subsections, and whether it creates a clear and unambiguous intent to set aside client-solicitor privilege for the auditor general to access the information for her investigation.
Richard Dearden, for the auditor general, told the court that Section 10 explicitly confirms on the AG's the right to access of privileged information even though one of the sub sections doesn't refer to privilege.
When questioned by the judge on that point, Dearden countered the three parts of the section must be considered in their entirety.
"You've got to read Section 10 as a whole, you've got to read 1, 2, 3 as a whole, and that subsection 3 is inextricably linked to what we see in subsections 1 and 2 of Section 10."
He said amendments included the words that the grant recipients, (ie Laurentian) "shall give" and the auditor general is entitled to have free access to a grant recipient's books.
He said subsection 3 was an entirely new provision that the Ontario Legislature added in 2004.
"It says that disclosure to the auditor general under subsection 1 or 2 does not constitute a waiver of solicitor-client privilege, litigation privilege or settlement privilege," said Dearden.
He added the exercise of that right is "another movie to be played on another date."
Run 3 Space | Play Space Running Game
Traffic Jam 3D | Online Racing Game
Duck Hunt | Play Old Classic Game
Two girls have been arrested in a swarming attack on a Muslim woman in Oshawa, Ont., and police say there is no evidence so far to indicate hate was a factor.
WARNING: This story contains disturbing descriptions of child sex abuse. Resources and supports for anyone who has experienced sexual violence can be found at the bottom of this story.
Montreal police have arrested a man who allegedly assisted billionaire Robert Miller by organizing a network to sexually exploit young women and girls.
Toronto police are investigating a homicide in the area of Highway 401 and Whites Road in Pickering.
Police have arrested a London man following a stabbing that left a downtown employee in critical condition.
A woman, 82, and a man, 77, have died after a collision in Uxbridge on Thursday, police say.
A Calgary-based firearms company says one of its rifles being classified as prohibited by the RCMP has thrown his business into "crisis mode."
Votes were cast using sticky notes, people tried registering for ballot kits using selfies as ID and more than 500,000 envelopes had to be ordered at the 11th hour as officials in Newfoundland and Labrador scrambled to switch to a provincewide mail-in election following a COVID-19 outbreak in 2021.
A man from Montreal is walking across Canada with a cart, a bike and his service dog, Timber and he's expected to pass through Sudbury, Ont., sometime next week.
On days the Halifax Wanderers play at home, Keara Turner can be found in the stands with an enthusiastic group of fans known as Privateers 1882.
As the sun beats down on a hot July day, a cool breeze drifts off the mighty Miramichi River flowing past the fields of the MacDonald Farm.
Norman Marshall Villeneuve, iconic drummer of the Canadian jazz scene known for his musicality, mentorship and spirited passion, has died. He was 87 years old.
Nineteen years ago, Gary Conway bought a ticket to the Winnipeg Folk Festival to hear singer-songwriter Bruce Cockburn.