Judge seeks more clarity on facts in supervised consumption site legal challenge
CBC
The Ontario judge overseeing the legal challenge of the province's ban on supervised consumption sites that are within 200 metres of schools and daycares unexpectedly recalled court Monday in a bid to understand whether he had all the facts to decide the case.
Justice John Callaghan heard arguments in late March from The Neighbourhood Group, which runs a consumption site in downtown Toronto. The organization, along with two of its users, argued the new law violates the Constitution and the Charter of Rights and Freedoms because the sites save lives.
The province says the legislation violates neither and its lawyers argued the case is merely about regulating the sites' locations.
The case drew numerous interveners, including neighbours who supported the government's new law and some who disagreed with the province's approach. Among the interveners was another supervised consumption site in Toronto, harm reduction workers and the City of Toronto's board of health.
But at issue for the judge are comments from Health Minister Sylvia Jones, whose office told The Canadian Press while the case was in court that the province would not allow new sites to open or allow current ones to move in order to comply with the new law.
Callaghan granted an injunction to allow 10 sites slated for closure because of the new rules to remain open while he considers his decision.
But nine of 10 sites slated for closure shut down anyway because they had agreed to transition to government-approved homelessness and addiction recovery hubs, or HART hubs as the province calls them, for about four times the amount of funding.
That caught Callaghan by surprise.
"I am a little concerned the record does not reflect some of the facts, such as nine of 10 sites didn't close because of legislation, but because of funding," Callaghan said.
He asked the lawyers if he needed more facts to properly decide the case.
Zachary Green, a lawyer for the province, said the judge had all the facts because the case doesn't focus on all the consumption sites or the minister of health, but rather on one site: The Kensington Market Overdose Prevention Site run by The Neighbourhood Group.
The judge asked that group if they wanted to update the submitted evidence, particularly to answer the question as to why the consumption sites closed despite his injunction.
Carlo Di Carlo, the lawyer representing The Neighbourhood Group, said he would need time to consult with his client.
But the group said it would try to get some new evidence into court, namely an article by The Canadian Press that quotes Jones's office.
Run 3 Space | Play Space Running Game
Traffic Jam 3D | Online Racing Game
Duck Hunt | Play Old Classic Game
The 10-year-old victim of a speedboat crash in North Vancouver on Saturday evening has been identified as Lionel Hall.
A Windsor father of two died from a fentanyl overdose at a local jail just days after being denied a prescription for a drug that treats opioid addiction, a coroner's inquest heard Monday.
Hundreds of members of Sandy Lake First Nation have left the remote Oji-Cree community as a major wildfire burns nearby.
A new collaboration that allows local artists to temporarily take over empty buildings in Waterloo region aims to "cut the red tape" normally associated with renting space.
The Charlottetown Library Learning Centre has added another language section to its multilingual collection.
An ambitious new plan aims to redefine the relationship between caribou and people in Yukon's Southern Lakes region, including by allowing Indigenous youth an opportunity to hunt the animals for the first time in decades.
Helicopter pilots, heavy machinery operators and railway workers are some of the people on the front lines of the Manitoba wildfire fight.
Ontario appears to be months behind launching a mandatory review of the Greenbelt, and opposition politicians and environmentalists are asking for a wide-ranging and transparent study of the protected lands to preserve their future.
WARNING: This article references sexual assault, and may affect those who have experienced them or know someone affected by them.
Former military language and cultural advisers — who at times carried out some of the most difficult and dangerous assignments of Canada's war in Afghanistan — are now suing the federal government for discrimination over the alleged failure to properly train and take care of them following their service alongside combat troops, CBC News has learned.
The 336-kilometre trail, which stretches along the coast of much of the Avalon Peninsula, has 25 different paths that people can take.
An organization that represents commercial fishermen says it's steaming ahead with a lawsuit aiming to define the terms of a moderate livelihood fishery now that a Nova Scotia-based First Nation has dropped its own lawsuit against the federal government.
Daniel DeLong was a Grade 12 student at Riverview High School in 2011 when his environmental science teacher encouraged him to get involved in his community.