Judge rejects former Tim Hortons baker's proposed class action
CBC
A B.C. judge has rejected a years-long effort by a former Tim Hortons employee to certify a class action lawsuit, which alleged that "secret" agreements between the fast food giant and its franchisees suppressed workers' wages.
Samir Latifi claimed that so called "no-poach" clauses in license agreements barred Tim Hortons franchise owners from hiring or seeking to hire each other's employees, intentionally causing economic harm to them in the process.
He argued that the clauses prevented workers from being able to move to other stores within Canada's largest fast food chain — which has more than 4,000 locations across the country — for better pay or working conditions.
Last week, B.C. Supreme Court Justice Neena Sharma dismissed Latifi's proposed class-action lawsuit, finding that the clauses were meant to increase profits and not necessarily to harm workers.
"He's disappointed," said David Klein, a lawyer representing Latifi. "He feels that it's an important case, that it should be allowed to move forward."
Over 100 Tim Hortons workers have also expressed interest in participating in the case since its launch in 2019, Klein added.
Latifi worked the graveyard shift as a baker at a Surrey, B.C., Tim Hortons in 2012. The Tim Hortons brand is owned by a holding company called the TDL Group.
According to court documents, the no-poach clause had existed in Tim Hortons' license agreements since at least 2003.
But TDL Group executives said the fast food chain stopped enforcing existing clauses or mandating them for new franchisees as of September 2018, according to the court decision, and complaints related to them happened "extremely rarely."
In her judgment, Sharma accepted that its no-poach agreement's primary goal was to benefit the franchisees and earn a profit for the company — not to injure workers.
In addition, the judge found that the expert evidence from Latifi's side, regarding the effects of no-poach clauses, didn't do enough to show TDL intended to harm its workers. She also said that he relied too much on U.S. studies and other types of similar employment restrictions.
Latifi's lawyers have already filed notice to appeal Sharma's decision as of May 21. TDL's lawyers declined to comment for this story.
Klein disputed the company's arguments, saying motivation for profit and the intention to harm workers were "two sides of the same coin." He argued that in order to retain workers, Tim Hortons franchisees could have instead provided better working conditions, higher wages or more opportunities for advancement.
"What they chose to do instead was to limit the other employment opportunities for employees," he said. "You can have a carrot or a stick, and they chose the stick."
Run 3 Space | Play Space Running Game
Traffic Jam 3D | Online Racing Game
Duck Hunt | Play Old Classic Game
Work on Windsor's large Banwell Road interchange and corridor construction projects is currently on hold after Butler's gartersnakes were discovered.
Etched on a poster board the size of her body, Mary McPherson held up a pencil-drawn portrait of Ontario Premier Doug Ford.
One of the largest old elm trees in Toronto — possibly in all of southern Ontario — is on its last legs.
It's graduation week for many University of Guelph students, but it's a particularly special day for one 68-year-old whose walk across the convocation stage was 49 years in the making.
Scientists on Prince Edward Island have created a new warning system to help Maritime farmers avoid a costly disease called fusarium head blight, which can decrease grain yields while contaminating the crop with toxins.
An N.W.T. deputy minister says the territorial government is hoping to use federal housing money to clear derelict homes from communities.
WARNING: This article contains graphic details, references sexual assault and may affect those who have experienced sexual violence or know someone impacted by it.
Monique Gordon's second-floor apartment in Rexdale is sweltering hot all year-round — even in the winter.
As Fanshawe works toward reducing its staff by more than a third, the college announced Thursday that 40 jobs have been eliminated through downsizing, early retirements and unfilled vacant positions.
Newfoundland and Labrador has unveiled a new online crime dashboard allowing users, with a click of a button, to see how their own communities rate against one another when it comes to violence.
Nova Scotia's whirlwind push to establish a uranium sector has yielded zero bids from companies interested in exploring for the critical mineral, a fact that left Premier Tim Houston unfazed Thursday and opponents of the industry relieved.
Premier Susan Holt says a second large-size nuclear power plant is back on the table to help address the growing demand for electricity both inside New Brunswick and beyond its borders.
Manitoba's premier says his government could use emergency powers to free up hotel rooms for people who escaped the wildfires still raging in the province's north.