Primary Country (Mandatory)

United States

Other Country (Optional)

Set News Language for United States

Primary Language (Mandatory)
English
Other Language[s] (Optional)
No other language available

Set News Language for World

Primary Language (Mandatory)
English
Other Language(s) (Optional)

Set News Source for United States

Primary Source (Mandatory)
CNN
Other Source[s] (Optional)

Set News Source for World

Primary Source (Mandatory)
AajTak
Other Source(s) (Optional)
  • Countries
    • India
    • United States
    • Qatar
    • Germany
    • China
    • Canada
    • World
  • Categories
    • National
    • International
    • Business
    • Entertainment
    • Sports
    • Special
    • All Categories
  • Available Languages for United States
    • English
  • All Languages
    • English
    • Hindi
    • Arabic
    • German
    • Chinese
    • French
  • Sources
    • India
      • AajTak
      • NDTV India
      • The Hindu
      • India Today
      • Zee News
      • NDTV
      • BBC
      • The Wire
      • News18
      • News 24
      • The Quint
      • ABP News
      • Zee News
      • News 24
    • United States
      • CNN
      • Fox News
      • Al Jazeera
      • CBSN
      • NY Post
      • Voice of America
      • The New York Times
      • HuffPost
      • ABC News
      • Newsy
    • Qatar
      • Al Jazeera
      • Al Arab
      • The Peninsula
      • Gulf Times
      • Al Sharq
      • Qatar Tribune
      • Al Raya
      • Lusail
    • Germany
      • DW
      • ZDF
      • ProSieben
      • RTL
      • n-tv
      • Die Welt
      • Süddeutsche Zeitung
      • Frankfurter Rundschau
    • China
      • China Daily
      • BBC
      • The New York Times
      • Voice of America
      • Beijing Daily
      • The Epoch Times
      • Ta Kung Pao
      • Xinmin Evening News
    • Canada
      • CBC
      • Radio-Canada
      • CTV
      • TVA Nouvelles
      • Le Journal de Montréal
      • Global News
      • BNN Bloomberg
      • Métro
Women's Floral Button-Down Shirt Buy Now
Vintage Printed Linen Shirt Buy Now
DUNLOP Waterproof PVC Boots Buy Now
4-Compartment Bento-Style Lunch Box Buy Now
Ripped Skinny Jeans Buy Now
Belted Wyoming Cargo Short Buy Now
CQR Mens Tactical Pants Buy Now
Viking Revolution Sea Salt Hair Spray Buy Now
Walnut Book Page Holder Buy Now
Cotton Military Outdoor Jackets Buy Now
3-Gear Electric Air Duster with LED Buy Now
100 Simple Healthy Recipes Buy Now
Phoenix Bracelet Buy Now
OYOANGLE Mens Baggy Dress Pants Buy Now
URAO Laptop Celeron N5095 Quad-Core Buy Now
Athletic Shorts for Women Buy Now
Business Dress Shirts Wrinkle Free Buy Now
Essentials Womens Fleece Short Buy Now
TCL 40-Inch 1080p LED Smart TV Buy Now
SHEWIN Womens Fashion Oversized T Shirts Buy Now
MoreBack to News Headlines
It is for historians to dig for tell-tale remains, not bigots
Premium

It is for historians to dig for tell-tale remains, not bigots Premium

The Hindu
Friday, December 20, 2024 6:56 PM GMT

The constitutionality of the The Places of Worship (Special Provisions) Act is under challenge in the Supreme Court of India

Normally, digging at historic sites is done by an archaeologist and historians in search of a lost civilisation or an ancient city or some signs of mythological events. But nowhere in the world, in the modern age, is an excavation done underneath a place of worship of one religion to find the remains of a place of worship of another religion. While digging in search of historical facts is a secular act, and is done using internationally recognised scientific methods, digging to establish the presence of a place of worship of one religion in a place of worship of another religion is, clearly, a non-secular act. Therefore, it is absolutely puzzling why the former Chief Justice of India (CJI), D.Y. Chandrachud found nothing objectionable or illegal in a survey in a place of worship of a particular religion by another religious group. In his oral observation, the former CJI, said, in 2022 (he was the CJI then), “a survey may not necessarily fall foul of the Places of Worship Act.” He made this tricky observation in the Gyanvapi mosque case.

The Places of Worship (Special Provisions) Act was enacted by Parliament in 1991 in the background of a strident movement by Ram Janmabhoomi supporters which heightened communal tensions in Ayodhya and many other parts of north India. The government of the day apprehended the imminent outbreak of violence in different parts of the country due to the raising of claims over the places of worship of a particular minority community. This Act bars the conversion of places of worship of any religious community into a place of worship of a different religious community. It declares that the religious character of a place of worship existing on the 15th day of August 1947, shall continue to be the same as it existed on that day.

The Act further provides that any suit and appeal seeking to convert the religious character of a place of worship existing on 15th August, 1947 pending before any court or tribunal shall abate on the commencement of the Act. It also states that no suit or appeal relating to this matter shall lie in any court after the commencement of the Act, and any suit alleging that the religious character of a place of worship has been converted after 15th August 1947 will be determined in terms of this Act.

But the constitutionality of this Act is under challenge in the Supreme Court of India. A petition was filed in 2020 challenging the constitutional validity of the Act on the grounds that the date of August 15, 1947 was fixed arbitrarily and that this Act takes away judicial review.

The contention that the date of August 15, 1947 was arbitrarily fixed in the Act to prevent the conversion of a place of worship is a specious one. This is the day when the transfer of power from the British government to the Indian government took place. Naturally, this was the earliest date the government could think of for the purpose of this Act. In any case, the Government of India could not have chosen April 21, 1526 when Babur defeated Ibrahim Lodhi in the battle of Panipat and captured Delhi and Agra and laid the foundation of the Mughal empire. Nor could it have chosen, arbitrarily, a later date and kept the field open for a set of religious fanatics to make reckless claims on the places of worship of another religion. Therefore, by all accounts, the date chosen by Parliament in this enactment was the most reasonable one.

The second ground cited in the petition is that the Act takes away judicial review which is a part of the basic structure of the Constitution of India and any enactment which alters it is unconstitutional. This contention, needless to say, is without any merit. The Act declares that from the commencement of the Act, all pending suits, appeal or proceedings seeking to convert a place of worship of one religion existing as on August 15, 1947 into that of another religion or altering the religious character of a place of worship shall abate. It is the legislative policy of the government to declare through a law that certain types of suits shall abate under certain circumstances. It is not the same as stating that “no court shall have any jurisdiction in respect of any suit arising from the place of worship of any religion”. The latter legislative assertion can be interpreted as an exclusion of judicial review which would, no doubt, be unconstitutional. But that is not the case here.

Subsequent to the above quoted observation of the former CJI, lower courts in the State of Uttar Pradesh are ordering surveys in mosques to determine their religious character with great alacrity. It has led to violence in Sambhal in Uttar Pradesh in which some lives were lost. The lower courts do not seem to have bothered to check whether it was an order of the Supreme Court or a mere observation of the CJI during the hearing. The fact is that such observations from the Bench have no significance as those are not a part of any judgment of the Court.

Read full story on The Hindu
Share this story on:-
Run 3 Space | Play Space Running GamePlay Run 3, the ultimate space tunnel running game with 300+ challenging levels!Adv.
Traffic Jam 3D | Online Racing GameTraffic Jam 3D is a game where you’ll be driving through heavy traffic.Adv.
Duck Hunt | Play Old Classic GamePlay the classic 1984 light gun shooter game Duck Hunt on your browser.Adv.
More Related News
ARTRAC commemorates 26 years of victory in Kargil War

ARTRAC commemorates 26 years of Kargil victory with patriotic celebrations, exhibitions, and felicitation for war veterans in Shimla.

What happened to the crypto exchange CoinDCX? | Explained Premium

Despite assurances, many CoinDCX customers moved to withdraw their assets, perceiving the event could turn into something like the WazirX hack last year.

Altermagnet conducts with different charge carriers in different directions Premium

Direction-dependent conduction polarity in CrSb allows it to act as both n‑ and p‑type parts of a circuit.

Fertile fields or solar factory: a verdant land facing an industrial leap Premium

Farmers and fisherfolk of the picturesque and fertile Karedu in SPSR Nellore district fear that the massive land acquisition for an ambitious industrial project may irrevocably hurt their livelihood, but the authorities are confident about hammering out a solution through dialogue and compensation

Gujarat: 16-year-old girl gangraped in Porbandar; duo arrested, two on the run

Four arrested for gangraping 16-year-old girl in Gujarat, two in custody, efforts on to nab other two.

Morning Digest: Almost 66 lakh voters may not make it to draft electoral roll in Bihar SIR exercise; Maldives President Muizzu thanks India for ‘pivotal’ economic assistance, and more

The Hindu Morning Digest gives a select list of stories to start the day. Read the top news today on July 26, 2025

Look at your own country: Bombay High Court raps CPI(M) over Gaza protest petition

Bombay High Court dismisses CPI(M) petition challenging Mumbai Police's denial of Gaza protest, sparking criticism and condemnation.

Depression over coastal West Bengal, extremely heavy rainfall, thunderstorms likely in the State: IMD

IMD forecasts heavy rainfall in West Bengal till July 31, warns of thunderstorms, waterlogging, and traffic disruptions.

Governor confers unit citations to armed forces units

Tamil Nadu Governor honors Armed Forces at Raj Bhavan for exceptional service, including 'Operation Sindoor' and disaster relief efforts.

Relief for 6,000 residents of Indira Colony as HC halts demolition drive

Delhi High Court halts demolition drive in Indira Colony, citing lack of due process, sparking political reactions.

World Mangrove Day: Tamil Nadu’s renewed efforts add nearly 3,000 hectares of mangroves in three years

Tamil Nadu government's ambitious mangrove restoration scheme aims to protect coastlines, biodiversity, and local livelihoods from climate-related risks.

N. Arun elected as CPI district secretary

N. Arun elected as CPI district secretary at conference with key party members present, delegates chosen for State conference.

In Bihar, a matter of life and debt Premium

In Bihar, increased borrowing from multiple sources, both institutional and informal lenders, has led to excessive debt burdens

Parking Slot | Free Parking GamePlay Parking Slot, the best online 3D car driving and parking game.Adv.
Slope Ball Run - Play OnlineSlope Game takes you on an exciting journey of a ball on special paths.Adv.
Andhra Pradesh Government aims to redefine tourism

Andhra Pradesh plans grand World Tourism Day celebration, focusing on unique experiences and partnerships with Mastercard's Priceless Experiences program.

Bihar Assembly polls: Nitish government hikes monthly pension of retired journalists by ₹9,000 to ₹15,000

Increase in pension for retired journalists in Bihar to ₹15,000/month, with lifetime benefits for dependents, announced by Chief Minister.

Cyclone havoc in Kannur: Elderly man killed, fisherman missing

Tragic incidents in Kannur district due to severe weather conditions, including fatalities and missing persons, prompt rescue efforts.

KKCCI seeks early environmental clearance for PM-Mitra Mega Textile Park

KKCCI urges Forest Minister to expedite environmental clearance for PM-Mitra Mega Textile Park in Kalaburagi district.

Tesla beats Chinese rivals in some driving assisted tests, say China state media, Bytedance

Musk’s Tesla outperformed Chinese rivals including BYD, Xiaomi and Huawei in a test of assisted driving technologies on China’s highways, according to results published by Bytedance’s auto unit Dcar.

What are cloudbursts?

What are cloudbursts? Why do we need to know about them?

Kargil Vijay Diwas: President Murmu, PM Modi lead nation to pay tributes to martyrs on 26th anniversary of ‘Operation Vijay’

26th anniversary of Kargil Vijay Diwas on July 26, 2025: Political leaders including President Droupadi Murmu and PM Modi led the nation in paying tribute to heroes

Meta names ChatGPT co-creator as chief scientist of Superintelligence Lab

Meta has appointed Shengjia Zhao, co-creator of ChatGPT, as chief scientist of its Superintelligence Lab, CEO Mark Zuckerberg said.

Govindachamy shifted to Viyyur Central Jail under heavy security

Govindachamy escapes Kannur jail, shifted to Viyyur Central Jail; security lapses prompt suspensions and increased inspections.

Light rains and weekend rush cause traffic snarls across Hyderabad and Cyberabad

Heavy rain in Hyderabad causes waterlogging, traffic delays on major roads in the city and Cyberabad on Friday evening.

Two Andhra Pradesh police officers killed in road crash

Two DSPs killed in road accident in Andhra Pradesh, additional officer and driver injured, investigation ongoing.

Why do mirrors flip left and right but not up and down? Premium

Mirrors don't flip left and right, but rather front to back, challenging common misconceptions about reflections.

© 2008 - 2025 Webjosh  |  News Archive  |  Privacy Policy  |  Contact Us