Higgs government loses legal bid to pay less for Fredericton-Moncton highway maintenance
CBC
The Higgs government has lost its legal bid to avoid paying more than $300 million to the company that built and maintains the Trans-Canada Highway between Moncton and Fredericton.
The New Brunswick Court of Appeal has ruled that the province had no legal right to challenge an arbitration decision that it should pay that amount to the Maritime Road Development Corporation.
The province, through a Crown corporation called the New Brunswick Highway Corporation, felt it should pay MRDC only $164.3 million for the final 10 years of the contract.
MRDC wanted $438.8 million.
The case revolves around a 195-kilometre stretch of highway that became a major political controversy as it was being built: a newly twinned road that, under an initial Liberal government plan in 1998, would require drivers to pay tolls.
The dispute was over what the province was required to pay MRDC for maintenance for the final 10 years of the contract from 2018 to 2028.
When they couldn't agree, the two sides went to an arbitration panel chaired by former Supreme Court of Canada Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin.
It came up with the figure of $307.6 million, close to the midpoint between the two numbers.
The province then tried to challenge that figure.
The New Brunswick Highway Corporation filed a motion with the courts asking for a ruling that it could challenge the arbitration decision on legal points.
But the judge hearing that motion said based on previous Supreme Court rulings, the province could only fight the award if there were a "palpable and overriding error," which did not exist in this case.
A three-judge panel of the appeal court has now upheld that.
"NBHC asks this Court to do exactly what the Supreme Court explicitly warned against," Justice Kathleen Quigg wrote in the decision.
Legal precedent "unquestionably instructs" that an appeal court can review a lower court's interpretation of a contract "only in rare cases," Quigg wrote.
Canada is preparing for U.S. President Donald Trump to hit the country with potentially devastating tariffs on Tuesday, but the federal government and the premiers say they are in the dark about what will actually materialize and how high those promised levies will be.
Former P.E.I. Premier Dennis King has been appointed as Canada's new ambassador to Ireland, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced Monday in a news release.
Oxford and Elgin counties have the highest number of measles cases in the country, the province's public health agency says, as local medical officials warn of more possible exposures to the deadly virus.
Ontario Premier Doug Ford will take questions from media Monday for the first time since his Progressive Conservatives won their third-straight majority in a snap election last week.
Newfoundland and Labrador is staring down federal, provincial, and municipal elections in the next eight months, but for one new Canadian the opportunity to vote is something she's not taking for granted.
Even with a dirt trench running down the hallway, and exposed wires and pipes hanging from the ceiling, it still kind of looks like an elementary school.
Some of the most affordable rental housing in Nova Scotia is rapidly becoming less so, according to Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation data analyzed by CBC News.
A two-time federal Conservative candidate in Miramichi says he doesn't think current party MP Jake Stewart can win again in a federal election that is expected to start within weeks.
Quebec municipalities and human rights groups are voicing concerns about proposed legislation that would require newcomers to abide by a set of common values.
Amazon and Walmart Canada have so far ignored the NDP government's requests to restrict the online sale of machetes to Manitobans, the province says.
Saskatoon city council is seeking money to crack down on unlicensed short-term rentals in the city, like those on AirBnB and VRBO, amid an active moratorium on licensing certain new short-term rentals.
When Kwaku Ayisi lost a friend who hadn't even reached 40 to breast cancer, it inspired him to look at the barriers Black women face in Saskatchewan's breast-health system.
A northern Alberta town is losing its only family doctor clinic and officials are trying to find solutions before the doors close for good at the end of May.