Ford's Greenbelt flip-flop could spell legal trouble for taxpayers, lawyers say
CBC
The Ontario government's sudden reversal on opening up parts of the Greenbelt for development could now put it and taxpayers in legal jeopardy for potential damages, some legal experts say.
Last month, Premier Doug Ford apologized to Ontarians and walked back the government's decision to remove 2,995 hectares of protected land from the Greenbelt to pave the way for housing development. The stunning flip-flop came after public outcry and separate inquiries from both the province's integrity commissioner and auditor general revealed major flaws with the process.
While critics of the plan cheered the reversal, lawyer Tim Gilbert said it's unlikely developers will forgive so easily.
"I don't think apologies go far enough. I think developers are interested in making money and building homes. That's what they're there to do," said Gilbert, managing partner at Gilbert's Law.
CBC Toronto spoke to several legal experts about the potential for civil liability, which comes as the RCMP launches a criminal probe into the matter.
In general, legal experts say governments are not held liable for decisions they make about land use. But some say developers that own the lands being put back under protection could sue the province to attempt to recoup money spent developing plans and investing in the required infrastructure. Others say those who bought land at a premium could also seek damages.
The protected agricultural land soared in value to about $8.3 billion after last November's initial Greenbelt opening announcement, Ontario's auditor general found in his report.
For instance, in 2017, Flato Developments spent $15 million on just over 41 hectares of farmland outside of Markham, Ont. Property. Corporate records show the company then sold about 29.5 hectares of that land to yet another development company, Torca UMV Inc., in April 2022 for $62 million.
About 4.5 hectares of that land was removed from the Greenbelt. Once the Ford government formalizes its reversal in legislation, nearly 15 per cent of the land will become once more undevelopable — and much less valuable.
Ford sidestepped questions last month about what the legal ramifications of the reversal might be, but Gilbert said he can see the government justify not paying anything by leaning into the fact that not much development has happened yet.
Still, Trevor Farrow, dean of York University's Osgoode Hall Law School, said developers could try to hold the provincial government liable for money spent on architects, designers and other experts hired to map out prospective builds.
"There's nothing normal about this situation at all."
Housing Minister Paul Calandra has stated that forthcoming legislation will include a provision to codify the boundaries of the Greenbelt and a provision to prevent developers from seeking compensation.
He argued despite the land being removed from the Greenbelt, no zoning had been changed and therefore the circumstances surrounding development never changed.
A pedestrian is dead after a vehicle crashed into a building in Toronto, said police.
RCMP in Inuvik, N.W.T., say two youth have been arrested after officers found suspected cocaine and a loaded firearm at a home in the community.
Canada and 13 other countries issued a joint statement Wednesday condemning the Israeli security cabinet's approval of 19 new settlements in the occupied West Bank.
Alberta health officials are flagging the circulation of a rare bacteria known as Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) among homeless adults living in Calgary.
The future of a prominent building in London's Old East Village (OEV), once home to the London Food Incubator, is looking uncertain following the relocation of its anchor tenant and the planned departure of another.
As Yukon continues to deal with a prolonged spell of extreme cold, emergency officials are advising people to be prepared in case of a power outage.
Police say they have found and arrested 47-year-old Douglas Yetman, a man wanted for murder.
Confirmed flu cases in northeastern Ontario are much higher now than they were at the same period last year.
The organization that represents some of America's largest spirits producers is calling for the NSLC to remove a policy that gives preferential markup to Nova Scotian spirit products.
Some energy experts are challenging N.B. Power’s claim that a proposed billion-dollar power plant is needed to avoid an electricity shortage predicted for 2028.
After walking a few laps around the shop, Maria Castagna picks up a glass ornament in the form of a pink, sparkly ice cream cone and smiles widely.
Winnipeg Mayor Scott Gillingham says he has much unfinished work from his first term in office, as he prepares to make his pitch to voters ahead of the 2026 election.
Moving to Canada from Singapore meant losing close social connections for Iris Akbar, but Akbar says the gift was in finding an affirming space with friends that became like family.