Feds, Assembly of First Nations move forward on reforming process to resolve historical grievances
CBC
The Assembly of First Nations (AFN) and the federal government are moving forward with steps to improve how historical grievances are resolved.
A working group launched earlier this month to develop options for consideration by the federal cabinet to reform the process, including addressing the government's conflict of interest in the management of specific claims by establishing a consensus-based independent centre to review claims.
"The immediate need is to remedy that, is to create an independent process that is completely separate from the federal government," said AFN Nova Scotia/Newfoundland Regional Chief Paul Prosper.
"The work has only begun and there are still some tough discussions ahead of us."
Specific claims deal with breaches of the Crown's legal obligations relating to treaties, the administration of lands and resources, and First Nations trusts. Currently, there are 318 specific claims in active negotiation and 173 still under assessment.
The Specific Claims Tribunal, an independent adjudicative body aimed at accelerating the resolution of claims, was established in 2008 as a part of the federal government's Justice at Last policy and joint initiative with the Assembly of First Nations.
It's used when claims have not been accepted for negotiation within three years, or could not be resolved through a negotiated settlement within three years. However, the tribunal or the commission currently has a cap of rewarding a $150 million in compensation for claims.
Prosper said while there have been improvements made over the years to the specific claims process, there still exists a significant involvement from the federal government when it comes to the management and funding of research into claims.
The centre wouldn't replace the tribunal, he said, but rather be a preliminary process used to help administer the management of claims.
First Nations have long advocated for an independent process, as the federal government is the defendant in claims yet controls funding, the review and acceptance of claims, and access to negotiations and evidence.
"They are the judge, jury and executioner," said Ratitsénhaienhs (Chief) Mike Delisle Jr., from Kahnawake, south of Montreal.
"For Justice Canada to be the go-to in terms of validating whether the claim is legitimate or not is obviously a conflict of interest."
Delisle worked on the Mohawk Council of Kahnawake's 300-plus year-old land grievance of the Seigneury of Sault St. Louis for over two decades. The federal government agreed to negotiate the grievance under Canada's Specifics Claims process in 2003 but there's been little progress in recent years.
Delisle said he'd like to see a more streamlined process that moves at an "adequate" pace including one that prioritizes the return of land.
Run 3 Space | Play Space Running Game
Traffic Jam 3D | Online Racing Game
Duck Hunt | Play Old Classic Game
This story is part of Resonate: Songs of Resilience in recognition of National Indigenous History Month and National Indigenous Peoples Day. CBC Indigenous with CBC Unreserved celebrates communities and families through music.
Indigenous and riverine communities in the Loreto region of the Peruvian Amazon have "chronic exposure" to mercury, according to a new study — and experts say the biggest culprit is gold mining in the region.
Anorexia is a life-threatening eating disorder that can manifest as an intense preoccupation on weight loss.
Students at Clearwater River Dene School in northern Saskatchewan took part in a fish camp last month as part of their school's land-based learning program where they practise language and cultural skills.
Inactive and abandoned oil and gas wells in Canada are a much bigger climate problem than previously thought, emitting almost seven times more methane than the official estimates, according to a new study from researchers at McGill University.
As the province's measles case count approaches 1,000, health experts are raising the alarm about Alberta babies who are being born already infected with the virus.
Sewing is a skill that you will have for a lifetime and it comes with many lessons. Some say it builds patience, care and focus.
It's taken a lot of work to rehabilitate the tiny patch of land at the centre of the small roundabout on Glen Drive and 10th Ave. in Vancouver, but for Katie Berlinguette, it was a labour of love.
The U.S. has approved the world's only twice-a-year shot to prevent HIV, its maker Gilead Sciences announced Wednesday.
Diane Marin has always been determined.
The Canadian government has yet to decide whether it would allow recycling spent nuclear fuel in the country, as the Nuclear Waste Management Organization (NWMO) announces it will be engaging with the public to choose a site for the nation's second deep geological repository.
About 44 per cent of men living in Canada die prematurely, according to a new report from the Movember Institute of Men's Health.
New data shows more people are filing complaints about obstetrical and gynecological care in Ontario, with insensitivity, poor communication and lack of trauma awareness among the most common grievances.