Driving ban not valid sentence for criminal negligence causing death, Supreme Court says in Sask. case
CBC
A Supreme Court of Canada ruling made this week in the case of a Saskatchewan man convicted of killing two people in a head-on collision says lower courts cannot impose driving prohibitions for criminal negligence causing death or bodily harm.
The top court says the ruling stems from a legal quirk in the Criminal Code caused by parliamentary amendments aimed at simplifying the code's language.
People guilty of lesser driving-related offences — such as dangerous operation of a motor vehicle causing death — can still receive driving bans, but not those guilty of criminal negligence causing death or bodily harm.
In a 5-4 split decision released Friday morning, the Supreme Court set aside the driving prohibition imposed on Braydon Wolfe, who was sentenced to six years in prison and a 10-year driving ban for killing two people in a highway collision near Langham, Sask., in 2017.
Wolfe drove his half-ton truck into the front of a sedan carrying Mohammad Niazi, his wife, Sangin, and their daughter, Zohal. The father and daughter died at the scene, while Sangin survived.
Wolfe was convicted of two counts of criminal negligence causing death and one count of criminal negligence causing bodily harm at what was then Court of Queen's Bench in Saskatoon. The sentence included two 10-year and one seven-year driving bans to be served concurrently.
In 2022, the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal upheld the prison sentence and the driving ban, but Wolfe appealed the driving ban to Canada's top court, which decided to hear the case based on national importance.
On Friday, the Supreme Court ruled in favour of Wolfe and his Saskatoon lawyer Katherine Pocha of Little and Company.
"Criminal negligence offences are not listed as offences that can attract a discretionary driving prohibition. They used to be listed, but are no longer," wrote Justice Sheilah Martin in the majority's decision.
In the dissenting opinion, Justice Mary Moreau wrote that "the majority's interpretation … produces the absurd consequence that a driving prohibition order can be imposed for a lesser offence, but not the principal offence."
The case is based on the statutory interpretation of the Criminal Code after Parliament amended the Criminal Code in 2018.
Previously, the list of offences for which a driving ban could be imposed included criminal negligence causing death or bodily harm. New wording in the 2018 amendments didn't specifically include those offences.
"So it became really murky," said Pocha in an interview Friday afternoon.
"The way that the new provision reads, it wasn't simplified, it wasn't coherent, and that's not consistent with the idea that people need to be able to understand these types of things clearly."
It was sometime in 2008 that Henry Walter got a message from his lawyer.
When Fredericton High School student Matthew Jeon wanted to start saving money for university, he started applying for summer jobs.
After yet another major flood at the Sainte-Croix Hospital in Drummondville, Que., family doctor Catherine Tétreault says the situation at the facility has reached a point of no return.
As the calendar is about to flip to an election year in Winnipeg, the time is growing short for candidates to mount a serious electoral challenge to Mayor Scott Gillingham.
Claude Hardenne occasionally tries out new packaging or moulds for his locally made chocolates, but he would never tinker with the recipes Harden & Huyse has used for almost 50 years.
The Supreme Court of Canada has upheld the first-degree murder conviction of the gang leader at the centre of the murder of Tiki Laverdiere.
As temperatures plunge and Islanders crank up the heat, the City of Summerside is preparing its power plans amid mounting pressure on P.E.I.’s electricity grid.
WARNING: This story details allegations of child abuse.
Ten years ago, Canada responded to the unfolding humanitarian crisis in Syria with an unprecedented program that rapidly resettled 25,000 Syrian refugees in roughly 100 days.
Alberta separatist leaders expect to start canvassing in January to get their independence referendum question on the ballot, thanks to the provincial government’s latest legislation to make it easier for them to succeed.
With the holiday season fast approaching, plenty of people are making a list and checking it twice. But for many in Thunder Bay, Ont., a hot meal is their number one concern of the season.
As Mayor Olivia Chow heads into what could be her final year leading Toronto — or final test before she asks voters to re-elect her in the fall — she’s reassuring ratepayers that they won’t see property taxes rise as sharply as they did earlier in her term.
Health Minister Marjorie Michel says she worries about how recent actions by U.S. public health agencies, like removing a universal hepatitis B vaccine recommendation for American infants, could hurt Canadians’ health.