District education council argues it needs to sue province to meet its mandate
CBC
The Anglophone East District Education Council says it has a right to sue the province over its gender identity policy because its job is to protect students and their rights.
But the province says allowing the council standing to sue would be an abuse of process and an unnecessary multiplicity of proceedings.
The council has filed a challenge to the section of Policy 713 that says teachers and staff need parental consent before using the chosen names and pronouns of kids under 16. The council alleges the policy violates the rights of 2SLGBTQ+ students under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and if the minister forces them to apply it, then they would be complicit in the alleged harm.
But before any constitutional arguments can be heard, the council has to prove that it has legal standing to bring the suit forward. Lawyers began making arguments on the issue Tuesday and have hearings scheduled every day this week.
At Court of King's Bench in Moncton, the province's lawyer, Clarence Bennett, said the district education council is a form of local government, so it does not have direct Charter rights that can be contravened. He said the council also does not directly represent 2SLGBTQ+ people in any "meaningful" way, since only two per cent of the people it represents identify as a member of the community.
But lawyers for the education council say its mandate is to ensure the success and the safety of the students in the district and to defend their rights. Council lawyer Perri Ravon said Policy 713 would also "force the DEC to violate the rights of the students."
"[This] makes their proximity that much greater, makes their standing … that much stronger," she said Tuesday.
Ravon said forcing staff to use a child's birth name without their consent, or using a pronoun they don't identify with, will cause harm.
The education council also wants to add Dominic Vautour to the list of plaintiffs, to represent parents who volunteer in school and are ruled by Policy 713. The province is challenging this, alleging there's a conflict of interest since Vautour is also a member of the education council.
Ravon said if the education council follows the policy, then it could be legally liable for infringing on the rights of the students in question. She said this puts the council in an "untenable legal situation."
The province's written submissions said because the education council is an agent of government, funded by the government, granting it standing to sue that same government would be a "perversion of ... the rule of law."
Ravon said that would be "news to the Supreme Court of Canada and the school boards across Canada," that have successfully sued in the past.
Court is scheduled to hear more arguments on this issue Wednesday. If Justice Tracey DeWare sides with the province, that will be the end of the education council's case. DeWare has not given a timeline for her decision.
With the B.C. NDP and B.C. Conservatives neck and neck heading into election day on Saturday, there are also a record number of Independent candidates who — if voted in — could hold the balance of power in a minority government scenario. British Columbians have only elected one Independent MLA in the last 60 years. Vicki Huntington won a seat in 2009 and was re-elected in 2013. But University of the Fraser Valley political scientist Hamish Telford said the situation could be different this election cycle. Of the 40 Independent candidates running, six of them are incumbent MLAs, who carry the benefit of name recognition in their community. "So we've got Independents in this election who I think we could deem to be viable shots at actually winning a riding, which is not normal," Telford said. "They're still long shots, but they are certainly plausible candidates."
Though Bill C-282 has received cross-party federal support in Ottawa, Alberta's provincial government says it's not a backer of the Bloc Québécois legislation that aims to prevent Canada's supply-managed sectors — dairy, poultry and eggs — from being included in future international trade negotiations.
A former Canadian Olympic snowboarder and 15 others are facing criminal charges for allegedly running a drug-trafficking operation that shipped hundreds of kilograms of cocaine from Colombia to Canada and used violence — including murder — to achieve the group's goals, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) announced Thursday.