Developer wins multimillion-dollar rent dispute with Vancouver School Board
CBC
A Vancouver developer will pay almost $8 million less in rent to the city's school board, after the B.C. Supreme Court issued a ruling on the school-owned Kingsgate Mall property.
Beedie Development Group is set to pay $1.65 million per year for the lease of the mall property until 2027, despite a 2022 tenancy arbitration panel ruling that said the rent should be $9.6 million per year.
Beedie appealed that ruling in the B.C. Supreme Court, arguing that the arbitration panel had misinterpreted an earlier 1999 ruling on the matter and it should pay a lower amount.
In a December decision released last week, the court agreed with the developer.
The Vancouver School Board says it's now evaluating its next steps in the matter.
Kingsgate Mall, on Kingsway and Broadway in East Vancouver, was first leased out by the city's school board in 1972. It is a 99-year lease, with an initial 25-year renewal period and a renewal every 10 years after that.
The first renewal term for the property came up in 1997. Neither the VSB, nor then-tenant Royal Oak, could agree on a lease amount, so the matter went to an arbitration panel in 1999.
That panel set a lease for the site, and ruled that the annual rent should be based on the land's immediate redevelopment value, and current use as a retail space.
Beedie took over Royal Oak's lease in 2005, paying $750,000 and then $760,000 a year. In 2015, they applied to renew the Kingsgate lease again, but once again the board and developer couldn't agree on terms.
The dispute led to the 2022 arbitration hearing, in which a panel rejected the 1999 hearing's interpretation and said the property's worth should be assessed off the value it could have if it took advantage of available upzoning.
The ruling increased the worth of the land to $116.5 million, and set the rent to $9.6 million per year.
Beedie argued the 2022 decision misinterpreted the 1999 ruling over what constituted "immediate" redevelopment value.
In her December decision, B.C. Supreme Court Justice Anita Chan agreed.
"Depending on how 'immediate' use is interpreted, the difference in the market value of the lands, and thus the rent, is significant."
After serving one term in city hall, Ward 12 Coun. Evan Spencer has announced he doesn't plan to return for a second.
The family of a Toronto man with a serious mental illness says he was left unconscious and on life support after he was involved in a violent clash with police at the end of December.
Toronto police have charged a 29-year-old woman with aggravated assault and two counts of arson after a man was found stabbed in a burning apartment unit on Friday morning.
A Nunavut researcher says more money and research is needed to understand how the availability of country food in Inuit communities is changing because of the warming climate.
This story deals with suicide. If you or someone you know has been the victim of sexual extortion, or is struggling with mental health, you can find resources for help at the bottom of this story.
This First Person column is the experience of Mark Datoc, who lives in Calgary. For more information about CBC's First Person stories, please see the FAQ. This story is part of Welcome to Canada, a CBC News series about immigration told through the eyes of the people who have experienced it.
Advocates working to fight homelessness say a report released this week by the Association of Municipalities of Ontario (AMO) confirms the reality they see on a daily basis, and highlights the challenges they've worked for years to make known to decision makers.
A series of rare photographs of rural Newfoundland were discovered in rural Ontario, but their true origins have opened up a bit of a mystery.
Sudbury's poet laureate, Alex Tétrault, was recently named one of 10 newsmakers of the year by Franco Presse, a publication focused on francophone communities outside of Quebec.
Ayah Fahmy recalls parking in a mostly empty lot at the Cobequid Community Health Centre in Lower Sackville and not understanding why she had to pay a fee.
More birds are making the trip north to New Brunswick this winter than usual, but the reasons probably aren't good.