David Chartrand calls Métis National Council allegations in lawsuit 'baseless'
CBC
The Manitoba Métis Federation (MMF) and its president David Chartrand are denying the allegations made by the Métis National Council (MNC) in a multi-million dollar lawsuit that says the MMF caused the MNC serious financial harm.
The lawsuit filed on Jan. 27 in Ontario Superior Court, alleges that in the lead-up to the MMF's departure from the MNC just before the MNC election last fall, the defendants "embarked upon a scorched earth policy" to cause financial harm to MNC, as the MNC and MMF would be competing to be the voice of the Métis Nation going forward.
The MMF and Chartrand, who was vice-president of the MNC until last fall, filed a statement of defence on Wednesday, in which they call the lawsuit the "latest salvo … in a broader political dispute over the representation of the Métis people."
The statement of defence accuses the MNC of having a political agenda "to secure power and influence amongst Métis people in Canada and to erode and ultimately usurp the MMF's position as the representative body of the Red River Métis."
None of the allegations have been proven in court.
Among the allegations are that $9 million from the $30 million Métis Veterans Fund Contribution Agreement was transferred to the MMF, breaching MNC bylaws and that a seven-year lease was signed for an MNC office in Ottawa at a higher-than-market rent, being paid to a landlord whose shareholders are associated with the MMF.
The MNC is seeking $15 million in damages, and another $1 million in punitive damages, as well as other forms of restitution, according to its statement of claim.
Chartrand said all the allegations are an attempt to misguide and mislead the Métis Nation.
"When you look at their statement of claim against us, it's baseless," Chartrand said, adding there is no money missing.
He said the rent on the MNC office in Ottawa was "way under — it's within the fabric of what rent costs are."
"In fact, they get more space and parking," he said.
"The most embarrassing part … we've given them notice …. You don't want to pay me rent, then move out of here, go find a place that you think is better out there. So that's the position they're in now."
Chartrand said the MMF will have an office in Ottawa and potentially offices across the Prairies.
The Métis Veterans Fund Contribution Agreement from the federal government was the result of over 20 years of advocacy over the discriminatory treatment in how benefits were distributed to soldiers returning from the Second World War, advocacy led by Chartrand, according to the statement of defence.
Elsie Yanik Catholic School in Fort McMurray, Alta., has been trying to build a teepee for a long time, according to the school's Indigenous liaison Michelle Janvier.
The Cree Nation of Mistissini and the government of Quebec signed an agreement to create the first national park in Eeyou Istchee, called Nibiischii Park, which translates to "land of water."
This story is part of CBC Health's Second Opinion, a weekly analysis of health and medical science news emailed to subscribers on Saturday mornings. If you haven't subscribed yet, you can do that by clicking here.
At 2 a.m. one morning in December, Mariah Gladstone asked herself: "Did I really just make a little gory buffalo butcher scene out of Sour Patch Kids and fruit leather?"
December isn't just about the holidays — it's also the time of year we get to enjoy what is often touted as one of the best meteor showers of the year: the Geminids.
A proposed deal that would see three tobacco giants pay out billions to provinces and territories, as well as smokers across Canada, has been approved by the companies' creditors, a lawyer representing some of the creditors says, calling it an important milestone in a lengthy legal saga.
With the Canada Post strike in its fourth week, Inuit and First Nations communities in remote areas are disproportionately feeling the strain.
Invasive species experts are asking those decorating for the holidays to check their trees, wreaths and garland for hidden pests.
Gilles-Francis Pone Shecanapish may not be able to talk about his experience being flown 500 kilometres to a psych ward, but his sister says the experience has left a mark on the 40-year-old who has severe intellectual disabilities and is non-verbal.
WARNING: This story contains details of deaths at residential schools.
Yvonne Russo says she had to see the world through the eyes of Annie Mae Pictou Aquash when directing and producing a new four-part documentary, Vow of Silence: the Assassination of Annie Mae.