Albertans could see pandemic-related charges withdrawn after ruling on Public Health Act breach
CBC
Albertans charged with breaking pandemic-related laws could see their charges withdrawn after a Calgary judge ruled the Public Health Act was breached when politicians, instead of the chief medical officer of health (CMOH), made final decisions on health restrictions.
The group funding the legal defence of two people and one church have called on prosecutors to withdraw charges after Court of King's Bench Justice Barbara Romaine's 90-page decision was released Monday.
The court action began in December 2020 when a group of plaintiffs — including two churches and a gym owner — filed a lawsuit arguing pandemic-related public health measures were contrary to Alberta's Bill of Rights and unlawfully breached Albertans' Charter-protected rights.
Romaine ultimately found former Chief Medical Officer of Health (CMOH) Dr. Deena Hinshaw made recommendations and ultimately implemented the restrictions, but it was cabinet which yeilded the final decision making power.
Alberta's Public Health Act does not allow for the CMOH to delegate her decision-making powers to politicians.
Now, the Crown must decide what to do with a number of prosecutions that were paused awaiting Romaine's decision.
That includes Ty Northcott's case. Northcott was charged after organizing and hosting an anti-lockdown rodeo which breached public health orders in May 2021.
Pastor James Coats of Grace Life Church in Edmonton as well as Calgary's Fairview Baptist Church also face charges related to breaches of public health orders.
"With these health orders having been invalidated, it is expected that Crown prosecutors will need to withdraw charges," wrote the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms (JCCF), which funds the legal defences for Northcott.
The Alberta Crown Prosecution Service (ACPS) says it's "in the process of reviewing the decision and assessing its potential implications."
"It will take some time to complete this thorough assessment. At this point, no decisions have been made as to next steps."
While it's not clear how prosecutors plan to move forward following Romine's decision, Lorian Hardcastle, a law professor specializing in health law at the University of Calgary, says she wouldn't be surprised to see charges dropped.
"I do think it's entirely possible that they may withdraw the charges given the orders weren't validly enacted at the time," said Hardcastle.
Hardcastle says now is the time for the government to fix the Public Health Act, clarifying who is the final decision maker and what is the role of CMOH.
Run 3 Space | Play Space Running Game
Traffic Jam 3D | Online Racing Game
Duck Hunt | Play Old Classic Game
More than a dozen residents of Richmond-Knob Hill have filed an appeal for judicial review against the City of Calgary's decision to approve the redevelopment of the former Viscount Bennet school site.
Conservative Party Leader Pierre Poilievre says he lost his riding of Carleton in the federal election due to an "aggressive" campaign by public sector unions after he was honest about wanting to cut federal worker jobs.
Phillip Campbell has been closely watching the skies to see which way the wind blows — and whether it will keep nearby wildfires at bay.
A second teenage boy has been charged in connection with the fatal stabbing of Abdoul Aziz Sarr, Toronto police said.
The Jurassic period is definitely over for a 10-year-old boy on Prince Edward Island, and a video representation of that passage of time has amassed millions of views on social media.
It's been a roller-coaster five years for the Toronto Fringe Festival.
He was once known as the most famous elephant in the world and more than a century after his death, Jumbo the elephant's legacy still lives on.
The federal government has started its comprehensive review of government spending, but what will it mean for Canada's public service, what balance will it have to strike and can the Liberals really cut so much?
Nova Scotia's alcohol enforcer and a craft brewery and restaurant in Inverness, Cape Breton, are far apart when it comes to the suggested penalty for contravening a liquor licensing regulation on the night the company's brewmaster died.
When Christopher Landry was making his annual trip to New Brunswick from New Hampshire, he didn't think he would run into any problems.
As home insurance costs rise sharply amid increasing extreme weather events, one advocacy group is calling for more transparency from Ontario's financial services regulator into the increasing rates.
Officials in Thompson are warning the roughly 13,000 residents of the northern Manitoba city to prepare for a possible evacuation in the coming days, as an out-of-control wildfire burns just north of the city.
The provincial government has investigated the discovery of a small amount of unsecured medical waste on a rural property in eastern Prince Edward Island.