Alberta government lawyers reject claim school mask mandate lifted due to 'combustible' border protest
CBC
Day 2 of a court hearing on the Alberta government's abrupt removal of a mandatory mask mandate for schoolchildren heard Thursday from a government lawyer who rejected a suggestion the decision was fuelled by growing tensions at the Coutts border in February.
"It is interesting that the applicants are trying to paint a picture that somehow the removal of the mask mandates was done for extraneous or improper purposes," said Gary Zimmermann, a lawyer representing the Government of Alberta.
The families of five immunocompromised children as well as the Alberta Federation of Labour (AFL) are seeking a review of the decision, which was made Feb. 8 during a cabinet meeting. Dr. Deena Hinshaw, Alberta's chief medical officer of health, presented a range of options to cabinet as the number of infections was falling.
A news conference was held later that day to announce the easing of restrictions.
The removal of the mandatory mask requirement for schoolchildren took effect on Feb. 14.
Lawyers for the group argued Wednesday that Dr. Hinshaw abdicated her authority to cabinet and failed to meet her obligation to protect medically vulnerable schoolchildren.
They said the decision to remove mask mandates in Alberta schools was not consistent with public health advice and instead was made by government officials for political reasons, including "quelling protests" at the Coutts border crossing.
On Thursday, it was the government's turn to respond.
"They refer to the combustible situation at Coutts, but I reiterate that there is no evidence that Dr. Hinshaw — or cabinet, for that matter — was motivated by politics in relation to this, anti-mask protests or the combustible situation at Coutts. There's no evidence of that," he told the Court of Queen's Bench hearing.
He said the decision was based on a number of factors, including falling case counts.
"The latest relevant stats, jurisdictional scans, science, efficacy of interventions … and that includes the fact that requiring children to wear masks is not without consequence," he said.
"The decisions … were absolutely made in good faith, using best judgment based on information available at the time."
He says students, guided by their parents, were allowed to make their own decisions regarding mask use.
"Thus, returning Alberta to the pre-pandemic status quo on this specific issue," he told the court.
Aggressive patients and lack of security are making nurses feel unsafe in a rural Western Manitoba emergency union, says the Manitoba Nurses Union.
Saskatoon resident Delynne Bortis knew her commute to work Tuesday morning would be particularly difficult.
WARNING: This story contains details of abuse and intimate partner violence:
The amount of money it takes for people to earn a living wage has increased across the province, according to a new report from the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (CCPA).
The new owner of Ontario steelmaker Stelco says his company "will not disappoint the people of Hamilton and Nanticoke," where the business's major facilities are based.
A Winnipegger is warning others about an intricate scam she says she almost fell for.
Fort William First Nation is opposing a planned redevelopment of the Ontario Power Generation's (OPG) 117 year old Kakabeka Falls Generating Station, which is located in their traditional territory.
A building that sits at the corner of Sussex Street and Brunswick Avenue has had many lives over the last century — being a church, a school and offices. Now it's set to become housing, at a time when the city sorely needs it.
A Waterloo, Ont., elementary school principal will be sentenced in the new year after pleading guilty to child sexual exploitation charges following a joint investigation that involved the London, Toronto and Waterloo police services.
Students at UPEI have let their student union know what they want from the province this fiscal year, and those priorities are reflected in a 2024-2025 advocacy document brought to the legislature on Wednesday.
Larger communities in the N.W.T. will soon see a boost in their territorial funding to maintain infrastructure and deliver services — like water and waste management — but the increase still falls short of what communities need.