Primary Country (Mandatory)

United States

Other Country (Optional)

Set News Language for United States

Primary Language (Mandatory)
English
Other Language[s] (Optional)
No other language available

Set News Language for World

Primary Language (Mandatory)
English
Other Language(s) (Optional)

Set News Source for United States

Primary Source (Mandatory)
CNN
Other Source[s] (Optional)

Set News Source for World

Primary Source (Mandatory)
AajTak
Other Source(s) (Optional)
  • Countries
    • India
    • United States
    • Qatar
    • Germany
    • China
    • Canada
    • World
  • Categories
    • National
    • International
    • Business
    • Entertainment
    • Sports
    • Special
    • All Categories
  • Available Languages for United States
    • English
  • All Languages
    • English
    • Hindi
    • Arabic
    • German
    • Chinese
    • French
  • Sources
    • India
      • AajTak
      • NDTV India
      • The Hindu
      • India Today
      • Zee News
      • NDTV
      • BBC
      • The Wire
      • News18
      • News 24
      • The Quint
      • ABP News
      • Zee News
      • News 24
    • United States
      • CNN
      • Fox News
      • Al Jazeera
      • CBSN
      • NY Post
      • Voice of America
      • The New York Times
      • HuffPost
      • ABC News
      • Newsy
    • Qatar
      • Al Jazeera
      • Al Arab
      • The Peninsula
      • Gulf Times
      • Al Sharq
      • Qatar Tribune
      • Al Raya
      • Lusail
    • Germany
      • DW
      • ZDF
      • ProSieben
      • RTL
      • n-tv
      • Die Welt
      • Süddeutsche Zeitung
      • Frankfurter Rundschau
    • China
      • China Daily
      • BBC
      • The New York Times
      • Voice of America
      • Beijing Daily
      • The Epoch Times
      • Ta Kung Pao
      • Xinmin Evening News
    • Canada
      • CBC
      • Radio-Canada
      • CTV
      • TVA Nouvelles
      • Le Journal de Montréal
      • Global News
      • BNN Bloomberg
      • Métro
Aldo Legoirii Tote Buy Now
Insignia Fire TV 32 inch Smart HD 720p Buy Now
Muscle Fit Dress Shirt Buy Now
Silk Satin Floral Shirt Buy Now
OptiPlex 7020 i5-14500T MFF Buy Now
Google Pixel 6a Android Phone Buy Now
Cross Pendant Necklace Buy Now
Womens Ribcage Straight Ankle Jeans Buy Now
OLCHEE Women’s Workout Sets 2 Piece Buy Now
Casio MDV106 Diver's Watch Buy Now
Kitchen Knife Set with Self-Sharpening Block Buy Now
STGAubron Gaming Desktop PC Buy Now
Multifunctional Cleaning Kit Buy Now
Men's Manicure & Pedicure Kit Buy Now
Motorola Moto G Stylus 5G Buy Now
Digital Camera for Photography 48MP Buy Now
Ripped Skinny Jeans Buy Now
3-Pack No-See-Thru Yoga Leggings Buy Now
Instant Hijab Scarf For Women Buy Now
Amazon Essentials Women's Heeled Sandals Buy Now
MoreBack to News Headlines
A tax on the unvaxxed would be legally and ethically questionable — even if it worked

A tax on the unvaxxed would be legally and ethically questionable — even if it worked

CBC
Thursday, January 13, 2022 10:01 AM GMT

The pandemic is now in its 23rd month and a highly contagious new variant is running rampant. Safe and effective vaccines are readily available and unvaccinated citizens are contributing disproportionately to a medical crisis that makes life harder and more dangerous for everyone.

So there are surely some — perhaps many — among the vaccinated who would like to see the unvaccinated suffer significant consequences for their intransigence, up to and including financial penalties. Ideally, such consequences also would minimize the number of people who remain unwilling to get the shot.

But however much Quebec's threat of a tax on the unvaccinated might appeal to feelings of frustration and desperation, it doesn't necessarily follow that Premier François Legault's proposal is the right way to go about confronting the problem.

Though the details have not been finalized, it does not seem that what Legault is proposing would run afoul of a strict reading of the Canada Health Act. That federal law — which Ottawa can enforce by withholding funding for health care from individual provinces and territories — specifies the principles of universality and accessibility. But Legault is not proposing a direct fee for necessary medical services.

Whether an annual tax on the unvaccinated undermines the idea of universal medicare is more of a philosophical or political question. Some might say it does.

But there are other big legal and ethical questions to ask about such a policy.

"The [Charter of Rights] argument that will be made is that basically, [you're] doing something coercive," said Lorian Hardcastle, a law professor at the University of Calgary.

"We probably will see people argue that [Quebec's proposal] violates the [charter] rights to life, liberty and security of the person. And there are cases that talk about [how] part of that right to life, liberty and security of the person is bodily autonomy and making your own medical decisions and the right to self-determination."

Charter rights aren't unlimited. They can be subject to reasonable or minimal impairments. That means it could fall on the Quebec government to justify the infringement.

"I think that this case would really turn on this question of, was the government reasonable in doing this? Do they need to do this? Could they have achieved increased vaccination rates through mechanisms other than this kind of coercive mechanism?" Hardcastle said.

"We don't ordinarily prescribe what health care treatments people must get … And so this is quite a jump, and we wouldn't want to make this jump if there were other stones left unturned."

A court might also want to know how effective the tax is at increasing vaccination rates. It could look to examples in Europe for evidence.

It's the degree of coerciveness, Hardcastle said, that separates a tax from other restrictions, such as barring the unvaccinated from accessing non-essential businesses or activities. When it comes to limits on movement, the unvaccinated have easy options. If they can't enter a restaurant, they can order delivery.

A number of other current public policies might seem loosely analogous to what Legault proposed on Monday – charges or regulations targeting unhealthy behaviour that can impose a cost on society.

Read full story on CBC
Share this story on:-
Run 3 Space | Play Space Running GamePlay Run 3, the ultimate space tunnel running game with 300+ challenging levels!Adv.
Traffic Jam 3D | Online Racing GameTraffic Jam 3D is a game where you’ll be driving through heavy traffic.Adv.
Duck Hunt | Play Old Classic GamePlay the classic 1984 light gun shooter game Duck Hunt on your browser.Adv.
More Related News
Police continue search for body of Jennifer Hillier-Penney

About 60 kilometres away from St. Anthony, on Newfoundland's Northern Peninsula, the RCMP is involved in a major undertaking down a long dirt road in an area known as Northwest Arm.

All scenarios being considered, RCMP say 5 weeks after N.S. children disappeared

A member of the RCMP's major crime unit says it's taking "longer than we hoped" to advance the investigation into two missing Nova Scotia children who vanished from a rural community more than five weeks ago.

Province will spend $6.5M to keep paramedic, EMT graduates in N.B.

The province has announced a $6.5-million bursary program for paramedic and emergency medical technician students that train in New Brunswick and commit to working in the province.

More victims, bloodshed were intended in sword attack at Brandon high school: police

WARNING | This story contains graphic details.

Sask. quietly ends its response to U.S. tariffs

In March, Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe announced his government's response to U.S. tariffs. Three months later, those measures are ending.

Uncontrolled wildfires keep Alberta on edge as thousands remain displaced

Even as firefighters get relief from extreme heat and harsh winds, Alberta's most dangerous wildfires are continuing to burn near communities under threat. 

It's 1 year until the 2026 FIFA World Cup. Is Vancouver ready?

One year out from the FIFA World Cup, questions remain about where soccer fans visiting Vancouver will stay and how much it will cost to keep the city safe. 

What vehicles are allowed in bike lanes? In Toronto, there is no one answer

Toronto needs a single set of rules for bike lanes in the city, a council committee decided on Wednesday.

Mother in Old Crow, Yukon, starts petition to clean up and improve recreational spaces

Living in a small and remote northern community like Old Crow, Yukon, can mean limited access to recreational activities — especially when many of the spaces meant for activities like baseball or soccer are being instead used to store industrial equipment and supplies.

Mark Carney has a national unity problem. A Liberal voice in Calgary might help

Viewed from a certain angle, it could be read as good news that only 30 per cent of Albertans believe their province would be better off on its own, a share that has grown only slightly over the last five years. In a hypothetical referendum, just 28 per cent said they would vote to secede. 

Toronto police identify boy, 15, fatally shot on weekend in Weston

Toronto police have identified a 15-year-old boy who died in hospital after he was shot in Weston neighbourhood on Saturday night.

Rob Lantz confirms he won't run for permanent leadership of P.E.I. Progressive Conservatives

Premier Rob Lantz says he won't seek the permanent leadership of P.E.I.'s Progressive Conservative Party, after previously saying people had been asking him to run for the position.

Alberta premier says province is looking to entice private-sector pipeline builder

Alberta Premier Danielle Smith says her government is working to entice a private-sector player to build a crude oil pipeline to coastal waters.

Parking Slot | Free Parking GamePlay Parking Slot, the best online 3D car driving and parking game.Adv.
Slope Ball Run - Play OnlineSlope Game takes you on an exciting journey of a ball on special paths.Adv.
New road closures in effect for Friday the 13th biker rally in Port Dover, Ont.

The only Friday the 13th of the year is coming up this week and for Port Dover, Ont., that means the return of the famous biker rally. 

Windsor Stellantis workers returning to 2 full shifts earlier than anticipated

Stellantis workers at the Windsor, Ont., assembly plant are returning to two full shifts a week earlier than previously expected. 

Wildfire smoke carries short- and long-term health risks, Alberta experts warn

As Alberta faces the prospect of another summer plagued by wildfire smoke, experts are urging people to monitor conditions and take steps to protect their long-term health.

Drug analyzer goes mobile in Thunder Bay, Ont., in wake of consumption site's closure

Before Justin Gill began working at NorWest Community Health Centres (NWCHC), he thought fentanyl was the most toxic substance impacting drug users in Thunder Bay, Ont.

New report details 'concerning' structural damage at Elizabeth Ziegler Public School

A crumbling façade is just the beginning of several major structural issues plaguing Elizabeth Zielger Public School (EZPS) in Waterloo, according to a long-awaited engineering report released Wednesday.

'Not here to scare people,' but P.E.I. watchdog raising alarm bells about historic debt levels

P.E.I.'s auditor general says the province's net debt, the highest in the province's history, is unsustainable.

Weight of traditional knowledge discussed at public hearing for Diavik's water licence

A handful of Indigenous governments want to see more criteria enshrined in the conditions of Diavik diamond mine's new water licence, to determine that water will be safe for cultural uses.

What you need to know about the G7 summit in Alberta

The news

G7: Why there is hope of a Carney-Trump tariff breakthrough at Alberta summit

Global trade will be a major focus at next week's G7 summit as world leaders gather in Alberta, including U.S. President Donald Trump, who will be making his first appearance at a major international event since returning to the White House in January.

As Toronto teen lay dying, witness says health centre ignored cries for help

Moments after he was shot in Toronto's Weston neighbourhood Saturday night, a teenage boy lay bleeding out in front of a local health-care centre — and one witness says her repeated cries for help at the facility's front door were ignored. 

2 cities, 2 buildings and 1 fugitive landlord leaves tenants in unlivable conditions

A wanted fugitive accused of being the ringleader of a grandparent scam has left tenants in two southwestern Ontario cities with a host of maintenance issues and no one to turn to for help. 

Are there 'snooping provisions' in Carney's massive border bill?

Conservatives and New Democrats don't agree on much, but it appears both have issues with provisions tucked into Bill C-2, the Carney government's Strong Borders Act.

© 2008 - 2025 Webjosh  |  News Archive  |  Privacy Policy  |  Contact Us