A tax on share buybacks will hit the oil and gas sector. Was that the whole point?
CBC
This week Ottawa announced its plans to introduce a tax on share buybacks, at a time when oil and gas companies have yet again reported windfall profits and additional share buybacks.
Buybacks are when publicly traded companies buy back a portion of their own shares on the stock market, at market prices. They are a way to reward existing investors, but also tie up cash that could be used to grow a business — or, in the case of oil and gas companies, pay for climate mitigation measures.
Cenovus, which launched a share-buyback program in November 2021, has since bought around 118 million common shares and delivered about $2.5 billion in returns to shareholders. The company's share buyback program is about to expire; it plans to apply for another one.
Canadian Natural Resources has returned about $5.1 billion to investors so far this year in share repurchases, up from approximately $940 million it spent on repurchases by this time last year.
Suncor has repurchased approximately $4.6 billion of its common shares this year, up from $1.7 billion by the end of September last year.
And ConocoPhillips has repurchased $6.5 billion of shares this year, up from $2.2 billion by this time last year, and has raised its existing share repurchase authorization by $20 billion.
With the new two per cent tax announced for 2024, Ottawa expects to bring in $2.1 billion over five years, and encourage companies to reinvest their profits in their workers and businesses.
But is the oilpatch being directly targeted by this tax, or does it just happen to be among the industries most affected — if not the industry most affected — by something the government would have done regardless?
Just days before the tax was introduced, Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault posted a video on Twitter criticizing the sector for how it's spending record-breaking profits.
"As Canadians see those profits, we need to see investment into cleaner energy, instead of share buybacks," he said.
"Dollars must start flowing," the minister said, into the plans energy companies have already announced for reducing emissions.
That follows a report earlier this fall from the Pembina Institute, criticizing the sector for spending too much on dividend payments and share repurchases, and not enough on decarbonization. (The Pathways Alliance, a group of large oil companies who've pledged their own net-zero targets, has disputed this characterization.)
"I think this is a recognition that we're not seeing these companies invest their record profits in reducing emissions, which is what needs to happen," said Jan Gorski, program director for oil and gas at the Pembina Institute.
But Martin Pelletier, a Calgary-based senior portfolio manager with Wellington-Altus Private Counsel, isn't so sure. He said the government likely had its eye on the oil and gas sector given how well it's doing, but believes its aim was more so to emulate a U.S. policy that could generate some extra government revenue, rather than to send a particular message.
Residents clapped, danced, sang and cried in the Anishinaabe community of Kitcisakik this week when the lights were finally turned on for the first time.
A man is suing three members of a Winnipeg family and a real estate broker he alleges used his intellectual disability to financially exploit him through property deals in Canada and India, leaving him out hundreds of thousands of dollars.
When Stephanie Gamble watched her mother model the first dress she made, smiling wide and walking an imaginary runway, she knew that was what she wanted to keep doing in her life.
'Tis the season for cuddling on the couch with a cup of hot chocolate and watching holiday movies. And for people in B.C.'s Interior, that can increasingly mean seeing their home communities on display.
Every year, snowy owls spread their wings and migrate down to the Prairies, where they enjoy access to plenty of rodent prey in vast open spaces.
This month has been a busy stretch at the Upper Room Food Bank in Charlottetown.
N.W.T. Education Minister Caitlin Cleveland says she has received the final report from an independent investigation into education bodies in the Dehcho region.
P.E.I.’s auditor general says he’s concerned and disappointed that the projected deficit has doubled what government initially estimated it would be — and he's urging the province to balance its budget.
A man found not criminally responsible for stabbing five people to death at a Calgary house party is getting more freedoms but not an absolute discharge.
A man has been found guilty of second-degree murder in the shooting death of a Toronto mother outside a supervised consumption site in Leslieville.
Russian olive trees — sometimes known as silver berry or oleaster — are small, ornamental plants with silvery leaves and black bark, and small yellow flowers and silver fruit that look like miniature olives. They’re pretty, but they’re a problem.
The Yukon Legislative Assembly’s fall sitting ended on Thursday after the territorial government introduced and passed a supplementary budget.
A Canadian military counter-intelligence operative, who stands accused of passing sensitive information to Ukraine, was involved in an investigation into allegations that a leading Canadian defence journalist was a longtime Russian asset.