A new reality for U.S. doctors as they navigate exceptions to shifting abortion laws
CBC
In 2012, Savita Halappanavar sought treatment at a hospital in Galway, Ireland; she was 17 weeks pregnant, in pain and miscarrying.
Her repeated requests for an abortion were ignored because of the presence of a fetal heartbeat, according to her husband. She died of septicemia — or blood poisoning by bacteria — 2½ days later.
Halappanavar's death is viewed as a pivotal moment in the abortion debate in Ireland, leading the country toward overturning its constitutional ban on abortion in a referendum six years later.
Pregnancy and the process of giving birth can be traumatic and carries inherent risks — everything from excessive bleeding to vaginal and other forms of tearing, cardiovascular problems and death.
The maternal mortality rate stands at eight per 100,000 in Canada, compared with 24 per 100,000 in the United States — a far higher mortality risk than that of a legal abortion procedure.
Doctors in the U.S. are now pointing to Halappanavar's death as an illustration of the thorny legal and ethical challenges ahead — as well as the potentially fatal consequences — following the overturning of Roe v. Wade.
According to Dr. Louise King, an expert in bioethics at Harvard Medical School, in many states, doctors will be left with the impossible task of trying to determine precisely when an intervention should be deemed medically necessary, as it was in the case of Halappanavar.
But if they act too quickly, she said, they could face the prospect of prosecution or fines under new or pending legislation, as roughly half of American states are expected to outlaw or severely limit abortion.
"It's complete absurdity, because it leaves [physicians] in these situations where they have no real choice," said King, who is also an obstetrician and gynecologist at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston.
"Broadly speaking, it removes an important option … from all persons who are pregnant in the United States, in states in which abortion is restricted."
In Missouri, for instance, there is an exception for a "medical emergency," while in Michigan, a law already in place only allows abortions "necessary to preserve the life" of a pregnant person. (That law is on hold pending a court injunction.)
Physicians say the specifics of these exceptions remain unclear.
Dr. Lisa Harris, an ob-gyn and associate chair at the University of Michigan, outlined her concerns in a widely circulated essay published in the New England Journal of Medicine earlier this year. It was then cited in the dissenting Supreme Court opinion on Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health, the case that led to the overturning of Roe v. Wade.
"What does the risk of death have to be, and how imminent must it be?" she wrote.
Run 3 Space | Play Space Running Game
Traffic Jam 3D | Online Racing Game
Duck Hunt | Play Old Classic Game
After graduating with a bachelor degree in mathematics from the University of Waterloo, Kareem Alfarra had hopes of continuing his studies in the United States.
This First Person article is the experience of Lori Osborne, a mother of four from Pimicikamak Cree Nation. For more information about CBC's First Person stories, please see this FAQ. You can read more First Person articles here.
Scientists in Canada are scrambling. Over the past few months, the U.S. government has cut billions of dollars in funding from scientific research as part of sweeping cost-cutting measures.
This story is part of Resonate: Songs of Resilience in recognition of National Indigenous History Month and National Indigenous Peoples Day. CBC Indigenous with CBC Unreserved celebrates communities and families through music.
Indigenous and riverine communities in the Loreto region of the Peruvian Amazon have "chronic exposure" to mercury, according to a new study — and experts say the biggest culprit is gold mining in the region.
Anorexia is a life-threatening eating disorder that can manifest as an intense preoccupation on weight loss.
Students at Clearwater River Dene School in northern Saskatchewan took part in a fish camp last month as part of their school's land-based learning program where they practise language and cultural skills.
Inactive and abandoned oil and gas wells in Canada are a much bigger climate problem than previously thought, emitting almost seven times more methane than the official estimates, according to a new study from researchers at McGill University.
As the province's measles case count approaches 1,000, health experts are raising the alarm about Alberta babies who are being born already infected with the virus.
Sewing is a skill that you will have for a lifetime and it comes with many lessons. Some say it builds patience, care and focus.
It's taken a lot of work to rehabilitate the tiny patch of land at the centre of the small roundabout on Glen Drive and 10th Ave. in Vancouver, but for Katie Berlinguette, it was a labour of love.
The U.S. has approved the world's only twice-a-year shot to prevent HIV, its maker Gilead Sciences announced Wednesday.
Diane Marin has always been determined.